Dissapointing F1s
#31
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: South Wales
Posts: 1,081
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ok going to stick with the Pirellis. F1s have done about 1300 miles, just as bad. Downright dangerous on the M4 especially on the curves by Newport. Overhyped underachievers - at least in 16 in size anyway. And the annoying thing is they don't even seem to grip as well! Double doh!
Thanks to all those who have commented, and will have a pair of F1s going cheap soon.
Cheers, cal
Thanks to all those who have commented, and will have a pair of F1s going cheap soon.
Cheers, cal
#32
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: South Beds
Posts: 401
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So are Toyo's better than F1's in 16" then? And how do S03's compare?
Sounds to me that Bridgestone could make a mint from us if the started producing the S02 again!! Or someone could if they found a lost container of them!
Sounds to me that Bridgestone could make a mint from us if the started producing the S02 again!! Or someone could if they found a lost container of them!
#34
Exactly what SiPie has said. My car was rolling all over the place with my new F1's until I changed the tyre pressures to 34 front, 32 rear. Now pretty good. Still wearing in though.
J
J
#35
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: South Wales
Posts: 1,081
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yep running 32.5 psi on the backs. Horrible, nasty feeling, easily the worst tyres ive had on all my cars ever for feel and lack of confidence. Will try and change them next week back to pirellis, all comparisons of my own, but I know whats right and whats not with the car, and those F1s have killed the handling, cheers cal
#36
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Western Canada
Posts: 3,344
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There seems to be conflicting info on pressures, can someone please confirm what they have found the best combination for 215/40x17 size Goodyears.
Cheers
Cheers
#37
Was running 205/50 16 S02's which i thought were brilliant. Changed to 215/40 17 F1 GSD3 and amazed to find them even better. However they did take about 1000 miles to really feel at home. Strangely they didn't feel harsher as I was expecting, and there is a little tread flex when new, but they just get better and better as they go on. Turn-in is sharper, grip unbelievable wet and dry, utterly predictable, which is so important. 34/32 psi.
Wore them out nearly and discovered there are cracks in the side-walls which I've got to get goodyear to look at, however I admit I have given them plenty to deal with and they've still lasted 25k.
I put the old 16 so2's back on last week. Surprisingly they are harsher to ride on and not noticeably softer on turn in, though they are less direct and will run wide earlier than the F1's under extreme cornering. Also noisier. Set around 33/31 psi.
I'd still buy more F1's for sure but next time might need 215/45s on a MY'03, so maybe the theory about the softer sidewalls in 50 profile, which seems to make sense from above, might prove to be an issue in that profile, and more so in 50's.
Oh, and that cracking, I'll keep you posted..
Wore them out nearly and discovered there are cracks in the side-walls which I've got to get goodyear to look at, however I admit I have given them plenty to deal with and they've still lasted 25k.
I put the old 16 so2's back on last week. Surprisingly they are harsher to ride on and not noticeably softer on turn in, though they are less direct and will run wide earlier than the F1's under extreme cornering. Also noisier. Set around 33/31 psi.
I'd still buy more F1's for sure but next time might need 215/45s on a MY'03, so maybe the theory about the softer sidewalls in 50 profile, which seems to make sense from above, might prove to be an issue in that profile, and more so in 50's.
Oh, and that cracking, I'll keep you posted..
#40
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Yorkshire.... Silly!!
Posts: 913
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
When I switched from the original Bridgestones on my STI7 to the F1's, I was instantly amazed by the dry and wet weather grip. On the whole I was very pleased with them.
Once I had given them a suitable running in period, I stepped up the pace in the twisties, and to my amazement a could hear scraping sounds in tight corners. At first I though it was my tyres catching the wings, but when I looked closer I noticed that my mud flaps were scraped on the bottom edge. Now there is a good 3 inch between bottom edge of mud flap and ground when the car is parked so I guessed that sort of suspension travel could be seen when pushing the car. So I put it down to the extra front end grip in the car making the suspension work harder.
This thread has got me thinking now, and maybe it is the tyre wall strength to a certain extent, maybe a bit of both. I know one thing though, when I checked my cornering speeds I noticed that I was taking them around 15-20mph faster... Extra grip does mean that more stresses are exerted on suspension and tyres.
Either way, I do agree with the comments about turn in not feeling as sharp as say other tyres. My old SO2's on my MY00 were fantastic, and I had them in both 16" and 17" when I switched wheels, both of which felt just as good as each other.
FWIW, I am running my pressures at 37/34. Much harsher ride, but it is kinder on my mud flaps
Answer to this one is, but 18" wheels and run them rubber bands
Cheers
Simon
Once I had given them a suitable running in period, I stepped up the pace in the twisties, and to my amazement a could hear scraping sounds in tight corners. At first I though it was my tyres catching the wings, but when I looked closer I noticed that my mud flaps were scraped on the bottom edge. Now there is a good 3 inch between bottom edge of mud flap and ground when the car is parked so I guessed that sort of suspension travel could be seen when pushing the car. So I put it down to the extra front end grip in the car making the suspension work harder.
This thread has got me thinking now, and maybe it is the tyre wall strength to a certain extent, maybe a bit of both. I know one thing though, when I checked my cornering speeds I noticed that I was taking them around 15-20mph faster... Extra grip does mean that more stresses are exerted on suspension and tyres.
Either way, I do agree with the comments about turn in not feeling as sharp as say other tyres. My old SO2's on my MY00 were fantastic, and I had them in both 16" and 17" when I switched wheels, both of which felt just as good as each other.
FWIW, I am running my pressures at 37/34. Much harsher ride, but it is kinder on my mud flaps
Answer to this one is, but 18" wheels and run them rubber bands
Cheers
Simon
#42
I had 16" S03s before the F1s on my 00, and the sidewalls were definitely stiffer with sharper turn in, but they were a lot noisier. I didn't find a tramlining problem with the S03s (ran these at 32/28). The GSD3s have better grip and sound very smooth, but have a slightly remote feeling even at 34/30. I suspect they would be fine on 45 or 40 profile so 17" wheels are tempting...
Bruce
Bruce
#43
Hi Guys,
Am running a Legacy GTB on F1's,these were on when I bought it,25% worn,215/45 17's,I will have no hesitation in replacing them with the same again.Have run several impreza's on Pirellis,Avons and Bridgestones,but the F1's are the most confidence expiring yet,the avons were IMHO sh*te,the pirelli's not much better.I think from all your threads and my experience with the tyres on my car that lower profiles (ie 17" wheels) seem to be the way to go with F1's...Hope this helps
Regards Blackwood
Am running a Legacy GTB on F1's,these were on when I bought it,25% worn,215/45 17's,I will have no hesitation in replacing them with the same again.Have run several impreza's on Pirellis,Avons and Bridgestones,but the F1's are the most confidence expiring yet,the avons were IMHO sh*te,the pirelli's not much better.I think from all your threads and my experience with the tyres on my car that lower profiles (ie 17" wheels) seem to be the way to go with F1's...Hope this helps
Regards Blackwood
#44
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: Bristol-ish
Posts: 2,085
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Running on 16" rims, at first I thought they were massively underinflated, but checked and were still at 32psi.
Not anywhere near as good as the S-02s that I had before.
You do expect a bit more movement with new tyres, but the sidewalls on the F1s are really soft, which probably doesn't help with the feel of the tyre.
I will up the pressure a bit, but am concerned at over-inflating them!
Not anywhere near as good as the S-02s that I had before.
You do expect a bit more movement with new tyres, but the sidewalls on the F1s are really soft, which probably doesn't help with the feel of the tyre.
I will up the pressure a bit, but am concerned at over-inflating them!
After a weekend in Wales, the front end now feels a lot more positive on turn-in, and confidence has returned.
So it seems that for the smaller diameter/higher sidewall tyres, an increase in pressure may make all the difference.....
#46
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Jury's out at the moment, managed to have a drive last nite but wasnt impressed after about 20 miles (maybe this is a bit early to make a judgement)
Front end seems very light on roundabouts and sharp corners, although i havent checked tyre pressures yet.
Straight line feeling is a MILLION times better than the 225/45/17 Potenzas which tramlined like a biatch and was very worrying.
Front end seems very light on roundabouts and sharp corners, although i havent checked tyre pressures yet.
Straight line feeling is a MILLION times better than the 225/45/17 Potenzas which tramlined like a biatch and was very worrying.
#48
Yeah, bring back the SO2s, they were superb! But don't buy the SO3s - the F1s are much better, especially in the wet. Turn-in isn't quite as sharp as I'd like, but 34/32 (16" rims) helps.
It's always a bit weird going from worn tyres to new "tippy-toes" treads. Possibly part of the reason the SO2s are so well remembered is that the compound got very soft as they wore down to road legal. Going from that to any new set is always going to be a let down, especially in the dry.
J
It's always a bit weird going from worn tyres to new "tippy-toes" treads. Possibly part of the reason the SO2s are so well remembered is that the compound got very soft as they wore down to road legal. Going from that to any new set is always going to be a let down, especially in the dry.
J
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
alexf
Wheels, Tyres & Brakes
9
14 October 2001 05:23 PM