View Poll Results: What type of car do you want from Prodrive?
Ultimate Performance on Road and Track
118
59.00%
Every day usability and performance
82
41.00%
Voters: 200. You may not vote on this poll
POLL: Prodrive - direction of car development
#181
Originally Posted by Supercue
What dealership Evo or Subaru is going to let me tool around a track on a test drive?? But you're right I didn't give the track time a thought but even so I've done enough track days to prove that a Scoob can match most cars around the track
Lets be honest 99% of my driving is on the road not the track otherwise I'd have gone for a Westie, Caterham or an Xtreme not a Scoob/Evo
But I'm glad you mentioned track days as I upset a FQ330 driver at Brands on the GP circuit He finished the session with smoke pouring from his brakes and couldn't match the times I was posting. He didnt believe that the car was not an Sti at least lol
oh dear "crack" what's that i hear ohhh it's mark opening his
"can 'o' whoopass"
#183
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Essex, England
Posts: 6,806
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by MattW
Just to state, I wasn't taking the p1ss, just pointing out for you (and for I and most other people) track performance is not a major consideration.
#184
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Poole - in an Isuzu D-Max LE (Prodrive Version) Gamer Tag "Coin Slot"
Posts: 1,485
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by hawkeye
i was/am very very tempted but still have a years manufacturers warranty left on my car so at the moment they dont factor
I'm sure Litchfield do a comprehensive warranty, Subaru warranty in my experience isn't worth the paper it's written on unless you have a competent main dealer near you (unlikely).
Afterall if it takes the countries biggest Subaru dealer 4 attempts to unsuccessfully fix my suspension rattle (not the usual near side rattle like others had) why bother ?
Any self respecting Subaru specialist would have fixed it first time.
Spec C/Type 25 plus a grand for a warranty and toast the Evo
#185
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Throwing myself down a mountain at every opportunity...
Posts: 6,794
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Bah I turn my back for 2 minutes and suddenly we are on page 10!!!
probably either the strut seal worn, the upper mount needs replacing or you have a loose bolt on your roll bar. Well that was the process to cure mine anyway
MIKE WOOD - can I just ask about the choice of tyre for the WR1??? It seems to me from both looking at the tyres on the car and also seeing the performance on TG they perhaps were not the best choice? It appeared the edges overheated drastically, which contributed to much of the understeer. I'm sure we all know what a difference tyre compound / profile / pattern makes so can you tell me how you came to that choice and if things like tyre pressure were set up before the press car was delivered to TG?
Can you also tell us if the ATD system is ever going to make an appearance (I hear rumours as to where it may make an appearance.) I'd love the chance to drive it again if you ever want another objective opinion now its moved on a bit, you can easily get snowblind working on the same thing...
Afterall if it takes the countries biggest Subaru dealer 4 attempts to unsuccessfully fix my suspension rattle (not the usual near side rattle like others had) why bother ?
MIKE WOOD - can I just ask about the choice of tyre for the WR1??? It seems to me from both looking at the tyres on the car and also seeing the performance on TG they perhaps were not the best choice? It appeared the edges overheated drastically, which contributed to much of the understeer. I'm sure we all know what a difference tyre compound / profile / pattern makes so can you tell me how you came to that choice and if things like tyre pressure were set up before the press car was delivered to TG?
Can you also tell us if the ATD system is ever going to make an appearance (I hear rumours as to where it may make an appearance.) I'd love the chance to drive it again if you ever want another objective opinion now its moved on a bit, you can easily get snowblind working on the same thing...
#186
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: where the wild roses grow
Posts: 5,122
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Without wanting to put words in Mike's mouth Ed, seems as though there's a fundamental difference between specifying a tyre for a road car and one that's going to be used on the track.
You will never load the tyres up to the extent, and for the time necessary to cause that sort of heating in a roadgoing context.
In the circumstances there's nothing in the TG piece that gives any clue to the tyre's performance on the road - good, bad or otherwise.
You will never load the tyres up to the extent, and for the time necessary to cause that sort of heating in a roadgoing context.
In the circumstances there's nothing in the TG piece that gives any clue to the tyre's performance on the road - good, bad or otherwise.
#187
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Throwing myself down a mountain at every opportunity...
Posts: 6,794
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
GM yeah I absolutely agree, but (and based purely on the evidence seen on TG) it appears the WR1 tyres are particularly bad on track. Thanks largely to the tyre wars in motorsport, there are an increasing number of tyres on the market now that are good in pretty much all circumstances...hard road use, good water clearance and also good on track (with the right tyre pressures).
My question is, given the amount of work no doubt done at the test track (which to be fair is probably as bumpy and scarred as some b-roads ) did they choose the tyres from an OEM cost perspective or a pure performance perspective??
My question is, given the amount of work no doubt done at the test track (which to be fair is probably as bumpy and scarred as some b-roads ) did they choose the tyres from an OEM cost perspective or a pure performance perspective??
#188
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Poole - in an Isuzu D-Max LE (Prodrive Version) Gamer Tag "Coin Slot"
Posts: 1,485
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
probably either the strut seal worn, the upper mount needs replacing or you have a loose bolt on your roll bar. Well that was the process to cure mine anyway
There's far too much dealer inconsistency and not enough communication through the various departments IMO[/off thread]
#189
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: 1600cc's of twin scroll fun :)
Posts: 25,565
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Originally Posted by MikeWood
On a slightly different point, has anyone actually driven a std JDM STi or Spec C as they are very different to how the press has driven the cars?
Mike, i now own a pretty much standard MY03 Spec C (just a hayward and scott b/box and an STi panel filter).
Its a great car but it isnt for everyone (most people just want it for its out and out performance, its not just about that though, its about the cars complete ability and rawness, which most people wont like) ie no electric windows, a/c (but mine for some reason came with this ) no central locking, no boot lining, no sound proofing etc etc etc, just a steering wheel, the A-DCCD and a seat (who needs anything else )
I think that alot of people dont understand when you say its a low spec car, its meant to be, in the same way the classic RA's were, its a car for competition, not really for every day use, but then having driven all sorts of vehicles (lots of landrovers and the odd 4 tonne truck ) im use to something more "rugged".
If you ever wish me to bring this car up/down to you then no problems, i was going to ask you if you had any Bridgestone RE070's hanging around, ok they tramline like hell and seem to take a while to bed in, but ive gotten use to them now and dont mind them so much
Tony
#190
gr8 thread.....
Some people on here at last seem to understand what MOST of us have been getting at.....the possibility of Prodrive/Subaru producing a real beast of an Impreza - a UK Spec or type 25 kind of car....most importantly including Mike Wood.
It's nice to see that you understand without throwing up all the usual excuses....no one on here expects miracles, it's just that there are somethings that can be done that i guess most of us cant understand why they havent been (basic suspension mods, geom changes, tyre choice, etc)...could you give us your thoughts on the reasons why your cars dont get sold to customers with a more optimized geom or better tyres, etc ?
No one is saying that the WR1 is a failure, sure u made the car exactly to the spec and and from my drive agree that its a good car point to point on UK bumpy roads. It still doesnt help that the equivelant EVO handles that little bit better (not sure thats the right word) and that Subaru currently already give us a 300Bhp understeering Sti. Think a few (or even a lot) of us were hoping you'd produce an "on tap oversteering 360+ bhp type of beastie"...(stroll on GM to quote me yet again..lol)
Mike, reading "We too would like to produce the ultimate Impreza......" is music to my ears. Maybe one day you guys will be given the opportunity by Subaru to do just that....i do honestly see a market for a more focused, track oriented impreza, after all why do so many of us go to such gr8 lengths, spending thousands on aftermarket mods ?...one view you could have would be that all that money spent on modifying could line the pockets of Subaru/Prodrive if they made a car like that in the 1st place.
Lastly, it's interesting seeing the results of the poll on here - it's clear for all (GM, Subaru and Prodrive - take note!) that most of us place most importance on Ultimate Performance.....almost 61% of us in fact.....
Come on Mike call IM/Subaru and suggest to them that there might be a few people out there that would buy something a bit "hotter" than a WR1, i think u guys with all your competition experience would love to make such motor.
It's nice to see that you understand without throwing up all the usual excuses....no one on here expects miracles, it's just that there are somethings that can be done that i guess most of us cant understand why they havent been (basic suspension mods, geom changes, tyre choice, etc)...could you give us your thoughts on the reasons why your cars dont get sold to customers with a more optimized geom or better tyres, etc ?
No one is saying that the WR1 is a failure, sure u made the car exactly to the spec and and from my drive agree that its a good car point to point on UK bumpy roads. It still doesnt help that the equivelant EVO handles that little bit better (not sure thats the right word) and that Subaru currently already give us a 300Bhp understeering Sti. Think a few (or even a lot) of us were hoping you'd produce an "on tap oversteering 360+ bhp type of beastie"...(stroll on GM to quote me yet again..lol)
Mike, reading "We too would like to produce the ultimate Impreza......" is music to my ears. Maybe one day you guys will be given the opportunity by Subaru to do just that....i do honestly see a market for a more focused, track oriented impreza, after all why do so many of us go to such gr8 lengths, spending thousands on aftermarket mods ?...one view you could have would be that all that money spent on modifying could line the pockets of Subaru/Prodrive if they made a car like that in the 1st place.
Lastly, it's interesting seeing the results of the poll on here - it's clear for all (GM, Subaru and Prodrive - take note!) that most of us place most importance on Ultimate Performance.....almost 61% of us in fact.....
Come on Mike call IM/Subaru and suggest to them that there might be a few people out there that would buy something a bit "hotter" than a WR1, i think u guys with all your competition experience would love to make such motor.
#191
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Solihull
Posts: 1,498
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's not a case of finally realising what everyone wants, we've known that since day one and I'm not talking the last couple of years, I'm talking about BEFORE the Impreza became famous. We are bigger petrol heads than you give us credit for.....
To answer some of your points, the geometry is optimised for ROAD use and the tyre we use is what we consider to fulfil the criteria we set for ROAD use. There seems to be a lot of talk about producing a track focussed car as well but there is a major sticking point here in that Subaru UK do not condone people taking the micky out of them by abusing their cars around a track and expecting Subaru to pick up the cost for the parts that fail prematurely as a result.
Some perspective needs to be applied here to the numbers as well, 61% is a nice majority but it's still only 107 that voted and how many will actually stump up the cash?
The discussions are ongoing and have not been influenced in any way by this thread.
Mike
To answer some of your points, the geometry is optimised for ROAD use and the tyre we use is what we consider to fulfil the criteria we set for ROAD use. There seems to be a lot of talk about producing a track focussed car as well but there is a major sticking point here in that Subaru UK do not condone people taking the micky out of them by abusing their cars around a track and expecting Subaru to pick up the cost for the parts that fail prematurely as a result.
Some perspective needs to be applied here to the numbers as well, 61% is a nice majority but it's still only 107 that voted and how many will actually stump up the cash?
The discussions are ongoing and have not been influenced in any way by this thread.
Mike
#192
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: here
Posts: 10,641
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For those that want Prodrive to provide a track focused car perhaps thay should ask Mike Wood what sort of deal he could do on a Prodrive Ferrari 550 GTS Maranello.
Darren
Darren
#193
thanks for getting back Mike....
Originally Posted by MikeWood
It's not a case of finally realising what everyone wants, we've known that since day one and I'm not talking the last couple of years, I'm talking about BEFORE the Impreza became famous. We are bigger petrol heads than you give us credit for.....
Originally Posted by MikeWood
To answer some of your points, the geometry is optimised for ROAD use and the tyre we use is what we consider to fulfil the criteria we set for ROAD use.
Originally Posted by MikeWood
Some perspective needs to be applied here to the numbers as well, 61% is a nice majority but it's still only 107 that voted and how many will actually stump up the cash?
Originally Posted by MikeWood
The discussions are ongoing and have not been influenced in any way by this thread.
Mike
Mike
Lastly , thanks for taking time out to get involved in this thread. Makes even more sense to be a member of this already good forum (there u go Mod's - I've kissed **** now PLEASE make that poll a tad more noticable...lol).
#194
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: 1600cc's of twin scroll fun :)
Posts: 25,565
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Originally Posted by Daz34
For those that want Prodrive to provide a track focused car perhaps thay should ask Mike Wood what sort of deal he could do on a Prodrive Ferrari 550 GTS Maranello.
Darren
Darren
Tony
#195
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Solihull
Posts: 1,498
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think you misunderstood my comments about this thread not influencing us. I didn't mean that we wouldn't take any notice, I meant that we already knew and have done for some time
On the subject of geometry, you will find that our recommended settings aren't very different to Powerstation's settings and we certainly don't 'tame' them to stop the lawsuits.
Mike
On the subject of geometry, you will find that our recommended settings aren't very different to Powerstation's settings and we certainly don't 'tame' them to stop the lawsuits.
Mike
#196
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: 1600cc's of twin scroll fun :)
Posts: 25,565
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Mike,
Have you voted?
I'll say i have, and it wasnt for the top one either
If you have 2 cars then you can use the scoob as a second car, if you only have one scoob and no second car then you want a good compromise and not a bone shaker.
Look further than just 0-60 and 0-100 times peeps, all round ability is better than just one area for every day useage.
Tony
PS, Mike DO you have any RE070's knocking around for a small charitable donation?
Have you voted?
I'll say i have, and it wasnt for the top one either
If you have 2 cars then you can use the scoob as a second car, if you only have one scoob and no second car then you want a good compromise and not a bone shaker.
Look further than just 0-60 and 0-100 times peeps, all round ability is better than just one area for every day useage.
Tony
PS, Mike DO you have any RE070's knocking around for a small charitable donation?
#197
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: where the wild roses grow
Posts: 5,122
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by whiteyisback
Surely even 107 people voting counts for something and gives you some insight as to what we want.
You also seem to be assuming that Scoobynet users = genuine cross-section of UK Subaru owners.
thats a shame....would like to have thought that the biggest Subaru forum might get a closer look by the manufacturer (and Prodrive) for some sort of customer feedback....
#198
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: The infamous 'Subaru Impreza Story' DVD Motor!
Posts: 1,107
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i'm just glad Subaru manufactured the Impreza full stop!
forget being outgunned by Evos getting crap crap write-ups or TV coverage. my car looks great, goes great, and gives me a big grin every time i...
hear the flat four rumble,
plant the throttle,
slingshot out of a bend,
turn some heads,
go to a meet,
get a wave from other owners,
help another owner,
etc...
and its just a lowly MY95 WRX... (with the obligatory mods of course)
forget being outgunned by Evos getting crap crap write-ups or TV coverage. my car looks great, goes great, and gives me a big grin every time i...
hear the flat four rumble,
plant the throttle,
slingshot out of a bend,
turn some heads,
go to a meet,
get a wave from other owners,
help another owner,
etc...
and its just a lowly MY95 WRX... (with the obligatory mods of course)
#201
I have to agree, I started looking at the wrx last yr, but decided to go for Audi TT (225bhp). What a mistake!!!!!!
Jan this yr I bought my 1st wrx with ppp kit. Which some git helped in writting off in april. I've just got my 2nd wrx but without a ppp kit on.
But it still leaves the biggest smile on my face every time i drive it
Jan this yr I bought my 1st wrx with ppp kit. Which some git helped in writting off in april. I've just got my 2nd wrx but without a ppp kit on.
But it still leaves the biggest smile on my face every time i drive it
Originally Posted by K9VYN
i'm just glad Subaru manufactured the Impreza full stop!
forget being outgunned by Evos getting crap crap write-ups or TV coverage. my car looks great, goes great, and gives me a big grin every time i...
hear the flat four rumble,
plant the throttle,
slingshot out of a bend,
turn some heads,
go to a meet,
get a wave from other owners,
help another owner,
etc...
and its just a lowly MY95 WRX... (with the obligatory mods of course)
forget being outgunned by Evos getting crap crap write-ups or TV coverage. my car looks great, goes great, and gives me a big grin every time i...
hear the flat four rumble,
plant the throttle,
slingshot out of a bend,
turn some heads,
go to a meet,
get a wave from other owners,
help another owner,
etc...
and its just a lowly MY95 WRX... (with the obligatory mods of course)
#202
has anybody thought about getting an imprezza and approaching prodrive to create something special for them???
forget the warranty and see what they can do (within reason)
im sure prodrive have a good idea what can and cant be done without opening up the engine......indeed Simon Lines has a classic with a new age engine in it
hmmmmm maybe I should be the Guinea Pig if prodrive were up for it I would!
paul
forget the warranty and see what they can do (within reason)
im sure prodrive have a good idea what can and cant be done without opening up the engine......indeed Simon Lines has a classic with a new age engine in it
hmmmmm maybe I should be the Guinea Pig if prodrive were up for it I would!
paul
#203
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: where the wild roses grow
Posts: 5,122
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by hawkeye
has anybody thought about getting an imprezza and approaching prodrive to create something special for them???
1) You wouldn't be able to afford it. Creating a car like the WR1 where the development cost is divided by 500 cars is one thing. How much do you think you'd pay for a one-off?
2) It would be commercially insensitive for Prodrive to supply roadcars into the UK market independently of IM. Indeed, their contract with IM/FHI may prevent them from doing so.
im sure prodrive have a good idea what can and cant be done without opening up the engine......indeed Simon Lines has a classic with a new age engine in it
hmmmmm maybe I should be the Guinea Pig if prodrive were up for it I would!
#204
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Essex, England
Posts: 6,806
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by hawkeye
hmmmmm maybe I should be the Guinea Pig if prodrive were up for it I would!
paul
paul
Yeah you, me and about 2million other Scoob owners LOL
PS Can't believe this threads still running
#205
thanks greasemonkey
I realised most if not all of your points above but it was just a thought, im sure prodrive have tried out different approaches and know what can and can't be done.
However with the knowledge they have and assuming that warranty wasn't an issue I do wonder what could be created for let's say £10000 + cost of donor vehicle
New JDM sti with dccd @£25000 + £10000 to prodrive = £35000 .... £5000 more than a Wr1 but I wonder what it would be like?
I realised most if not all of your points above but it was just a thought, im sure prodrive have tried out different approaches and know what can and can't be done.
However with the knowledge they have and assuming that warranty wasn't an issue I do wonder what could be created for let's say £10000 + cost of donor vehicle
New JDM sti with dccd @£25000 + £10000 to prodrive = £35000 .... £5000 more than a Wr1 but I wonder what it would be like?
#206
Originally Posted by Supercue
Yeah you, me and about 2million other Scoob owners LOL
PS Can't believe this threads still running
PS Can't believe this threads still running
Mike im game if you are i'll put my money where my mouth is!!
#208
Originally Posted by greasemonkey
It's a non-starter for two reasons:
1) You wouldn't be able to afford it. Creating a car like the WR1 where the development cost is divided by 500 cars is one thing. How much do you think you'd pay for a one-off?
1) You wouldn't be able to afford it. Creating a car like the WR1 where the development cost is divided by 500 cars is one thing. How much do you think you'd pay for a one-off?
2) It would be commercially insensitive for Prodrive to supply roadcars into the UK market independently of IM. Indeed, their contract with IM/FHI may prevent them from doing so.
Of course. However, Simon's car is Simon's car, not a "Prodrive project"
For the reasons stated above I'd suggest it's very unlikely to happen. No harm in trying though.
paul
#209
Originally Posted by Supercue
Phone up Mike and ask him Paul I'm sure he'll come up with something if you have the bucks to back any project.
Worst he can do is say no
Worst he can do is say no
a. because if mike's read this i'm sure he's in-consolable and creased up with
laughter
b. Is probably flying down to the pub in simons car to drown his sorrows
c. Lost the will to live due to ANOTHER of my posts
OR
He may have a moment of madness and take me up on the offer
paul
#210
Originally Posted by SC008Y_MAD
I think that they should be producing/making cars like the Type 25 as the standard WRX and a super type 25 as the STi model, and then a super duper model something like Type 25 R etc...
then they should be able to caine the oposition e.d Mitisubishi EVO's
...but obviously priced ocordingly with current models.
then they should be able to caine the oposition e.d Mitisubishi EVO's
...but obviously priced ocordingly with current models.
As for the flat 6 with twin turbo..........
Any news on the first performance model with this engine - I would happiliy accept 400 lb ft from 2000rpm!