Mountain Bike - which one for around £450
#31
Originally Posted by the moose
I'd buy second-hand at that price. Seriously, almost anything for the £200 mark will be heavy, slow, and pretty poorly constructed.
Then again, I'm a terrible bike snob.
Then again, I'm a terrible bike snob.
go used at that money.
#32
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Dumbria
Posts: 375
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by gregjd
Sorry to hijack the thread but what bikes would you recommend (if anything!) for around the £200 mark? I certainly don't need anything flash for the amount of use I'd make of a mountain bike! I'm moving out to the sticks though and could do with a bike now I'll be living too far from a gym.
Another good source is ex-hire bikes, they are rarely kept more than six months because the shops use them to reduce their tax bill, they are well maintained usually, one thing to watch for are hubs without and grease because of pressure washing but apart from that they are cracking value for money are most have rarely gone offroad.
Also some shops do trade-in nowadays and often have a little book with the second hand stuff in.
#33
Originally Posted by anc-sti
So you recon a professional bike shop who has been dealing with mountain bikes for twenty years compares to Halfords. Do me a favour!! Support your local bike shop they have a wealth of experience you simply will not get from a Car accessory shop.
Both can be staffed by numpties both can be staffed by people with a wealth of knowledge with years of experience. While i agree it is better to support your local business men, few can offer the competative pricing and large range that a halfords bikehut can offer.
#34
Originally Posted by druddle
I found out yesterday that there is a government initiative to get people cycling to work, and inconjuction with Halfords, the government will pay 40% of the cost of a bike (up to 1000 quid i think) plus money off helmets and that sort of thing.
Not sure of a URL, something me Mum showed me last night cos her partners work have just said about it (LLoyds TSB).
Dave
Not sure of a URL, something me Mum showed me last night cos her partners work have just said about it (LLoyds TSB).
Dave
http://bbs.scoobynet.co.uk/showthread.php?t=367001
You could get your £450 bike for under £300 by a clever little tax wheeze WELL worth a look.
#35
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Far Corfe
Posts: 3,618
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Brother_Will
What i do take um-bridge at is your over generalizing both about halfords and about local bike shops, just because its local and has been around for years doesn't mean its better. I've been in local shops where mountain bike is a dirty word, likewise I've been in halfords where the only thing they know about is £99 full suss bikes.
Both can be staffed by numpties both can be staffed by people with a wealth of knowledge with years of experience. While i agree it is better to support your local business men, few can offer the competative pricing and large range that a halfords bikehut can offer.
Both can be staffed by numpties both can be staffed by people with a wealth of knowledge with years of experience. While i agree it is better to support your local business men, few can offer the competative pricing and large range that a halfords bikehut can offer.
Tis true I'm afraid, there are quite a few roadie type shops that dont have anything to do with mountain bikes at all. Thats their choice. There are good and bad amongst any trade. So a good idea is to get some personal recommendations. I remember seeing some young lad that came along to our MB club where the local Halfrauds bike hut people had mangled his hyd brakes up with mole grips cause they didnt know what they were doing. Most couldnt build a wheel....... Its easy to be a bike snob, just like watches and cameras I suppose. At the end of the day buy something you are happy with and that feels comfortable. If you're not doing radical things with it most bikes will do.
Good luck.....
#36
Scooby Regular
My first ever mountain bike was a Diamond Back Ascent. I was 16 and worked all summer to save up the £400 for it, which back in '89 was a lot of money.
I bought it from the local "specialist" bike shop and it fell to bits after a week.
Turned out that a mate worked there and he told me the boss just paid kids to build any bikes that came in cos he couldnt be bothered, needless to say I never went there again.
However, our current local bike shop is very good and knowledgable. ALmost bought a Scott Elite Racing from them last year.
I bought it from the local "specialist" bike shop and it fell to bits after a week.
Turned out that a mate worked there and he told me the boss just paid kids to build any bikes that came in cos he couldnt be bothered, needless to say I never went there again.
However, our current local bike shop is very good and knowledgable. ALmost bought a Scott Elite Racing from them last year.
#37
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Dumbria
Posts: 375
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Brother_Will
What i do take um-bridge at is your over generalizing both about halfords and about local bike shops, just because its local and has been around for years doesn't mean its better. I've been in local shops where mountain bike is a dirty word, likewise I've been in halfords where the only thing they know about is £99 full suss bikes.
Both can be staffed by numpties both can be staffed by people with a wealth of knowledge with years of experience. While i agree it is better to support your local business men, few can offer the competative pricing and large range that a halfords bikehut can offer.
Both can be staffed by numpties both can be staffed by people with a wealth of knowledge with years of experience. While i agree it is better to support your local business men, few can offer the competative pricing and large range that a halfords bikehut can offer.
I know if I went to a Halfords and asked about my next race bike, that I would know more about the bike industry than the person serving me, this doesn't fill me with confidence. Thats just me and my opinion after biking for 20years and racing mtbs for 15 years, hay ho..
As has been said before not all shops are equal find a good one you can't go wrong. I use Biketrek's in Ambleside but live in Cockermouth(30miles away) there are many shops closer but I trust the guy's they don't sell crap, there knowledge is second to none and they have a discount system if you are loyal. An example of the way they work is; They used to be one of the main dealers of pace forks which were very good 5 years ago, recently the new generation have been plagued to reliablity issue's because of this and negative feedback from customers they stopped dealing pace and started pushing other forks which work. This results in more satisfied customers.
Guess it's all about what you want and what your priorities are.
Last edited by anc-sti; 06 October 2004 at 12:56 PM.
#38
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Oct 1998
Location: London
Posts: 4,891
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Maybe too late, but The Hub at Glentress are doing Giant XTC3s, brand new, for £500. They're also doing ex-hire ones (about 3 months old) for £400. They're cracking bikes - Alu frames, Manitou Axel forks, mostly XT groupsets, and hydraulic discs.
If anyone's interested, drop me a line (or call them direct). They'll post the bikes to you if you can't get up to Scotland.
Oh, and re: Halfords, having worked in the workshop at the Hub for 9 months last year, and having seen the sheds that came in that people had bought from Halfords (inappropriate to their needs, badly built-up, and in some cases plain dangerous to the customer) I would recommend that people steer clear of Halfords and go to their local bike shop every time.
If anyone's interested, drop me a line (or call them direct). They'll post the bikes to you if you can't get up to Scotland.
Oh, and re: Halfords, having worked in the workshop at the Hub for 9 months last year, and having seen the sheds that came in that people had bought from Halfords (inappropriate to their needs, badly built-up, and in some cases plain dangerous to the customer) I would recommend that people steer clear of Halfords and go to their local bike shop every time.
Last edited by MarkO; 07 October 2004 at 08:35 AM.
#40
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: No longer Japan !
Posts: 1,742
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You could buy British and get an Orange Gringo Disc. You might well be able to get an '04 model for 450, though they are priced at 650 usually. Good bits, Deore all round, and a strong frame worth upgrading with hydraulics later if required.
#43
A mate has just bought the Gringo non disk and is chuffed to nuts with it. I notice that the disk version is cable rather than hydraulic.
I have the Giant XTC4 with hydraulic disk which I much prefer, it means that you don't get the same stretch as with a cable and you have a lot more control near the limit (the experts call it modulation i think!!) Guys I have met with cable disks have all said they wish they gad gone for the hydros.
I'm no expert, but i have had the bike about 7 months and love it. Having had an early no sus bike for the previous 10 years and hardly used it I now get out at least twice a week for 2-3 hours (which is about the maximum I can fit in between family and work)If you can get one cheap in the sales, I strongly recommend it.
Cheers
Andy
I have the Giant XTC4 with hydraulic disk which I much prefer, it means that you don't get the same stretch as with a cable and you have a lot more control near the limit (the experts call it modulation i think!!) Guys I have met with cable disks have all said they wish they gad gone for the hydros.
I'm no expert, but i have had the bike about 7 months and love it. Having had an early no sus bike for the previous 10 years and hardly used it I now get out at least twice a week for 2-3 hours (which is about the maximum I can fit in between family and work)If you can get one cheap in the sales, I strongly recommend it.
Cheers
Andy
#44
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Dumbria
Posts: 375
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hmmm, Orange british company so I was keen to support them in a mainly American Industry. Had two nice bikes but both broke, my P7 snapped the down tude and my E3 fractured the chain stay. Both bikes were under warranty so no problem there. But after two failures I decided to get a more durable machine, a Fat Chance Yo Eddy this bike has done 5 hard years on the lakeland fells and is as good as the day I bought it. Its been superseeded by a S-Works Epic but thats just I'm getting soft and wanted a full susser.
Not sure how durable the current models are but it put me off ever buying from them.
Not sure how durable the current models are but it put me off ever buying from them.
#45
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Dumbria
Posts: 375
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by MarkO
Oh, and while I'm at it, anyone interested in buying a classic '96 CinderCone ?
http://www.otway.com/mtb/cindercone1.jpg
http://www.otway.com/mtb/cindercone1.jpg
#47
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Cambridge
Posts: 1,428
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I test rode the gringo disk and hated it, And ive always wanted a orange felt heavy and unbalanced, brakes were next to useles and exspensive.
I went for the giant xtc 3 from pauls cycles, excellent frame and xt components, not 100% sure about the integrated headset but its holding up so far. And the forks are pretty good for this price range too.
I went for the giant xtc 3 from pauls cycles, excellent frame and xt components, not 100% sure about the integrated headset but its holding up so far. And the forks are pretty good for this price range too.
#48
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Oct 1998
Location: London
Posts: 4,891
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Fat Chance Yo-Eddy. One of my dream frames. Always used to look longingly at that when I used to hang around at Cycology in Crowthorne in the mid-90s.
Andy, you're right - mechanical discs are pointless; most of the advantages of disc brakes are lost if you still have the problems associated with cables. I'd always recommend hydraulic. That's why the XTC3s are such a bargain (particularly at £500 new; I gather it's 'cos the Hub overstocked and then didn't need as many for hire bikes).
Imlach - if you're interested in the CinderCone, let me know. It's a 16", but quite large relative to 16" bikes these days (I'm 6ft...). Bear in mind the frame doesn't have disc mounts on it though.
I'm selling just the frame and forks (80mm Duke Races), 'cos the groupset's going on my new frame:
Andy, you're right - mechanical discs are pointless; most of the advantages of disc brakes are lost if you still have the problems associated with cables. I'd always recommend hydraulic. That's why the XTC3s are such a bargain (particularly at £500 new; I gather it's 'cos the Hub overstocked and then didn't need as many for hire bikes).
Imlach - if you're interested in the CinderCone, let me know. It's a 16", but quite large relative to 16" bikes these days (I'm 6ft...). Bear in mind the frame doesn't have disc mounts on it though.
I'm selling just the frame and forks (80mm Duke Races), 'cos the groupset's going on my new frame:
#49
MarkO - I don't need discs for now, so no disc mounts would be fine on the CinderCone.
I'm 6'2", so 16" should JUST be ok I think......
(edited - Oops - are you just selling the frame? Ah well...maybe a XTC3 then...)
Saying that, I'm may be tempted by a XTC3! I have sent you PM and email about this....
I'm 6'2", so 16" should JUST be ok I think......
(edited - Oops - are you just selling the frame? Ah well...maybe a XTC3 then...)
Saying that, I'm may be tempted by a XTC3! I have sent you PM and email about this....
#50
Scooby Regular
I can vouch for the Giant XTC's that are on hire at Glentress. Cracking bikes and well up to the job of any of the routes in Glentress. We've hired about 6 of their bikes when I've been too lazy to take me own
Stefan
Stefan
#52
Scooby Regular
Antime's fine with me. Just need a few days notice to keep a day free.
My bikes getting rebuilt just now, but it's just as easy hiring one of the Giant bikes from the Hub.
Stefan
My bikes getting rebuilt just now, but it's just as easy hiring one of the Giant bikes from the Hub.
Stefan
#56
Former Sponsor
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: www.scoobyworld.co.uk
Posts: 1,987
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
had a trip round the bike shops this PM, and found a Kona Explosif & Cinder Cone for £700 - brand new. But whats the better of the 2?
Looks a beauty - worth it? Would be a stretch £££ but maybe worth it?
Neil
Looks a beauty - worth it? Would be a stretch £££ but maybe worth it?
Neil
#57
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Dumbria
Posts: 375
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by NeilT
had a trip round the bike shops this PM, and found a Kona Explosif & Cinder Cone for £700 - brand new. But whats the better of the 2?
Looks a beauty - worth it? Would be a stretch £££ but maybe worth it?
Neil
Looks a beauty - worth it? Would be a stretch £££ but maybe worth it?
Neil
Both these frames used to be steel, I know Kona changed the cindercone to Alloy, don't know about the Explosif, is it Steel or Alloy?
Edit:
The Explosif is still steel, excellent bike. Steel is more forgiving than alloy but weighs more. Therefore if you are going for steel you have to go for a quality frame of which the Explosif is one, because they have been manufactured as light as possible. Keith Bontrager once said if steel cost as much as titanium all high end bikes would be made of it!! Steel is also more durable than alloy and the tudes aren't critically damaged if they are dented.
I may be biased is I rode a steel Fat Chance Yo Eddy for many years.
http://www.konaworld.com/kw_index.cfm
http://www.konaworld.com/2k3/bikes_m...if_300x4in.jpg
Last edited by anc-sti; 09 October 2004 at 06:33 PM.
#59
Former Sponsor
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: www.scoobyworld.co.uk
Posts: 1,987
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
well, bit the bullet today and bought the Explosiv and just gotten back from an off road run - including a fast downhill section.....and wow - what a bike - very very impressed by it!!.
I used to go biking with a mate who had a Trek 8000 ( I think) and he used to leave me for dead on the downhills - will certainly give him a run for his money now!
Excellent bike well worth the money (£720) chuffed to bits
Thanks for all those who replied with advice
cheers
Neil
I used to go biking with a mate who had a Trek 8000 ( I think) and he used to leave me for dead on the downhills - will certainly give him a run for his money now!
Excellent bike well worth the money (£720) chuffed to bits
Thanks for all those who replied with advice
cheers
Neil
#60