Notices
Non Scooby Related Anything Non-Scooby related

Dutch Murder

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 14 July 2005, 10:53 AM
  #31  
RedFive
Scooby Regular
 
RedFive's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 570
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by bigsinky
the brainwashing had to start somewhere. a normal run of the mill guy just dont go out and stab someone for dissing islam unless he has some pretty bad issues.
The knife incident had nothing to do with his religion.

Red 5 : from what I saw, the article presents no evidence of his family current employment status or even if his parents actually spoke Dutch.
Look, other than personally escorting you to the kitchen in Schiphol, I can not provide "evidence". IIRC his parents, being 1st generation, don't speak Dutch (but might speak French, as many people from Morocco/Algeria do), I didn't state that BTW.

Furthermore, a cynical reader would also point out that an article posted on such a site could not be expected to be a true representation of the original. I could post something here purporting to be a copy/paste from The Economist susscription site and you wouldn't know if that was really the case or not?
Erm... what good would it do to provide a link on here to a subscription site ? It may be a surprise to you that "on such a site" there are actually about 50% Dutch non-muslims who'd be very glad to point out any factual errors. If it helps, the article was posted/copied by a Dutch PHD (can't trust them furriners can you )

One of the theories behind radicalisation is indeed that the first generation failed to integrate and therefore set a very poor example to their offspring ,who end up without any true sense of belonging. Hence the regression to fundamentalism. It's a theory to which I personally subscribe.
There is no doubt the first generation mostly did not integrate. Not because they don't want to, but because they mostly work hard for low wages, having had no education at all.

It is also a known fact that their children get a much better education, and are stuck between the old culture of their parents and their new country. They are also faced with blatant or covert racism/exclusion, and often start to have a real dislike for "the West". They revert to what is called "invented tradition", and become much more "fundamental" in their thinking than their parents (who often haven't got a clue about what is happening with their kids) ever were.

The "problems" in Holland & Belgium are almost never with the 1st generation, but with the better educated 2nd generation who speak fluent Dutch. The last few years however showed a massive change in that the 2nd and 3rd gen now drops out of school very early. Only 30 % of them finish with some kind of qualification, which means 70 % of those kids have no outlook in life. That is an earth shattering number IMHO.

In any case, it's clear that multi-culturalism has comprehensively failed, so social inclusion and integration is the only way forwards.
"Integration" has become a tarnished word for many of them. They feel like they are forced to "assimilate". And the 70% dropouts doesn't make it look like we are working on social inclusion.

P.S. How comes you can read Dutch?
Me mum thought me
Old 14 July 2005, 11:01 AM
  #32  
RedFive
Scooby Regular
 
RedFive's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 570
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Chris L
No it's not - saying you're do something and actually doing it are very different things. You're arguing between whether it is 0.00001% or 0.0000001% (for example) of Muslims that have a fanatical issue or belief. The point is, it's such a small minority, you can't tar an entire belief or nation with the same brush.
We are overestimating the role of the religion, but perhaps you are underestimating the "anti-Western" feelings of many of them Chris. They - rightly or wrongly - feel spat out by society (I always felt that the UK was a much better place in that respect), and have nothing good to say about their new home countries. That to me is the most worrying thing. We *do* have a problem, but it's not a religious one. Many use religion as a coathanger, but many do not. In a few years time, that might be a much bigger problem than the religious fanatics.

Anyway, as the article I mentioned is "suspect", I'm not going to bother translating it if you don't mind. If only it would have been posted on Scoobynet first
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
GaryC
ScoobyNet General
69
06 September 2001 01:56 PM
Dario
ScoobyNet General
4
22 March 2001 08:50 PM
Dario
Interior
1
22 March 2001 06:26 PM
Orville
ScoobyNet General
2
15 November 2000 07:30 PM
epyjymp
ScoobyNet General
7
09 February 2000 06:20 PM



Quick Reply: Dutch Murder



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:10 AM.