What class would you place yourself in?
#31
My parents were lower working class from the point of view of my father's income after he left the Army. My parents were very upright people for all the difficulties they had to overcome.
I was lucky to go to a very good school because of the 11 plus exam instituted by the post war Labour government who were honourable people and who worked for the good of the electorate and for altruistic reasons.
Because of my education I was able to get a commission in the RAF as a career. I am unable to say which class that put me into, maybe middle class of a kind, hard to say. We all came from a very wide section of society, from top to bottom, and that taught us a lot as to how to treat life in general. All I can say is that I loved every minute of my time in the Service and shall always be grateful to the people who gave us all that opportunity at the time.
Of course you can always better yourself if you have the will and with a modicum of luck on the way.
Les
I was lucky to go to a very good school because of the 11 plus exam instituted by the post war Labour government who were honourable people and who worked for the good of the electorate and for altruistic reasons.
Because of my education I was able to get a commission in the RAF as a career. I am unable to say which class that put me into, maybe middle class of a kind, hard to say. We all came from a very wide section of society, from top to bottom, and that taught us a lot as to how to treat life in general. All I can say is that I loved every minute of my time in the Service and shall always be grateful to the people who gave us all that opportunity at the time.
Of course you can always better yourself if you have the will and with a modicum of luck on the way.
Les
#32
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: God's promised land
Posts: 80,907
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The most bizarre definition of middle class i've ever heard
#33
Scooby Regular
Well, it's more so traits etc....
I live in the Countryside. Despite being well-educated, and having to talk for a living, my Herefordian accent does tend to slip out (not that I try to hide it, I hasten to add). Wifey is the same - she's from the Black Country. Her parents have very broad accents, yet she has none at all (with the exception of some words).
My Working-class values I *think* focus on family - a head of the family, the fact that both myself and Wifey work (according to the Marxist definition of the term).
Another trait is that I've got Working-class friends and family, and the fact that I relate with them (God, how pompous does THAT sound!!! - although I do have some friends who WON'T interact with people who they consider are lower than them - an opportunity too good to miss for a bit of an argument!!LOL!! )
Then there's the hot potato regarding Politics but I'll conveniently side-step that
Does this make any sense (trying to make sense of it myself tbh!! )
Dan
I live in the Countryside. Despite being well-educated, and having to talk for a living, my Herefordian accent does tend to slip out (not that I try to hide it, I hasten to add). Wifey is the same - she's from the Black Country. Her parents have very broad accents, yet she has none at all (with the exception of some words).
My Working-class values I *think* focus on family - a head of the family, the fact that both myself and Wifey work (according to the Marxist definition of the term).
Another trait is that I've got Working-class friends and family, and the fact that I relate with them (God, how pompous does THAT sound!!! - although I do have some friends who WON'T interact with people who they consider are lower than them - an opportunity too good to miss for a bit of an argument!!LOL!! )
Then there's the hot potato regarding Politics but I'll conveniently side-step that
Does this make any sense (trying to make sense of it myself tbh!! )
Dan
#34
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Going further than the station and back !!! ZZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzz
Posts: 11,097
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#35
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: God's promised land
Posts: 80,907
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think it's generally true that lower class families are closer-knit, yes. But it's not the preserve of the working class (and not in Dedrater's ultra-literal sense of the phrase). Politics is indeed contentious, lots of people vote Labour becuase they deem themselves to be working class, and that's that. But then i'd never vote Labour if they were the last party standing, so it cuts both ways. In the end class is irrelevant, but it does make me giggle when people will argue to the ends of the Earth that they're "only" working class, as if it's a badge of honour. Funny.
#41
#42
Scooby Regular
If you even read up just a little social psychology you'll understand that.
In the political sense maybe, if you were a politician? But other than that I can't see it. Is Gordon Brown upper class?
#43
Yeah I know, I tried not to base Class on education or money, then did so right at the end.
What I tried to get at, was, Class must be about, Power/Influence and working for the 'man'
If you are not in a working hierarchy system where someone has seniority or authority over you, but still are able to influence/have power over others.
Bit of a brain wrecker this one
What I tried to get at, was, Class must be about, Power/Influence and working for the 'man'
If you are not in a working hierarchy system where someone has seniority or authority over you, but still are able to influence/have power over others.
Bit of a brain wrecker this one
#44
I dont think you can really pigeonhole the entire population into basically two categories plus a few under "upper class", it also depends on perception, I may sound a bit posh to someone from Ordsall but a bit common to someone from Prestbury.
It isnt all about wealth but its a factor, but again its perception, to some friends of ours they thing we are loaded, and it has to be said we are a lot better off and spend a lot more, but to some other friends you get the feeling they feel like we are a bit poor but they have 100k cars and swimming pools.
There are now a lot of scuffers who do nothing and expect it all and people with a few quid, a big 4 by 4 that think they are special and above everyone else.
It isnt all about wealth but its a factor, but again its perception, to some friends of ours they thing we are loaded, and it has to be said we are a lot better off and spend a lot more, but to some other friends you get the feeling they feel like we are a bit poor but they have 100k cars and swimming pools.
There are now a lot of scuffers who do nothing and expect it all and people with a few quid, a big 4 by 4 that think they are special and above everyone else.
#45
Scooby Regular
Not really. Least not to me.
If you work, you are working class. Is that not the case?
Middle class I always thought was if you were financially independent.
Upper class is if you were landed gentry or aristocracy.
All this upper working, lower middle is for Daily Mail readers.
If you work, you are working class. Is that not the case?
Middle class I always thought was if you were financially independent.
Upper class is if you were landed gentry or aristocracy.
All this upper working, lower middle is for Daily Mail readers.
#46
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Stroke it baby!
Posts: 33,828
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not really. Least not to me.
If you work, you are working class. Is that not the case?
Middle class I always thought was if you were financially independent.
Upper class is if you were landed gentry or aristocracy.
All this upper working, lower middle is for Daily Mail readers.
If you work, you are working class. Is that not the case?
Middle class I always thought was if you were financially independent.
Upper class is if you were landed gentry or aristocracy.
All this upper working, lower middle is for Daily Mail readers.
Using that definition would you place a university professor or surgeon in the working class category?
#48
I think to be upper class you would need to hold at least a Peerage; Duke, Baron, Lord of Parliament etc
But then if you go down this route the House of Lords and House of Commons would come into it and that's a game I don't want to play.
But then if you go down this route the House of Lords and House of Commons would come into it and that's a game I don't want to play.
#49
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: A big town with sh1t shops: Northampton
Posts: 21,366
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think it's more to do with your outlook on life and your principles.
What are dole scroungers and chavs? Are they "working" class and if so, is this country fcuked?
What are dole scroungers and chavs? Are they "working" class and if so, is this country fcuked?
#51
Scooby Regular
These financial money men with £1m bonus are still workers.
You could argue that assuming they become financially independent and stop working (as apposed to retire) they then become middle class.
A harder person to quantify would be some tree hugger who has no need of material possesions and money who needs not work and lives off the land. Should he be classed as middle class. I would say a tramp with a purpose but others might disagree.
How is class defined?
By your history
By your profession
By your current salary
By the size of your house
By how many cars you have
By how much debt you are in
How many items of The North Face clothing you have
Or
Lower class - the great unwashed workshy pikeys of sink estates
Working class - everyone who must work to keep a roof over their head
Middle class - financially independent
Upper class - aristocracy
Last edited by EddScott; 30 December 2009 at 03:17 PM.
#52
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: A big town with sh1t shops: Northampton
Posts: 21,366
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#54
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: England
Posts: 2,785
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
IMHO Classes are made so the rich can feel better. there's nothing i hate more than snooty people who think they are better than you because of money or whatever else. In my life ive met people from all sorts of backrounds, and the ones i respect/value/admire most are the ones with true loyalty, or the ones who are most honest, so in my view classes are peoples decency.
I was seeing a girl last year, her dad was multi millionaire, diddnt have to work if he chose not to but he did,so upper class?? but he was a prize ****. His daughter thought she was better than everyone else as she had more money. She used to joke, referring my home and surrounding area as being a council estate. Every house is 4 bed or more, houses valued from around £3 to £7 hundred K. Not lots in some peoples views but not poor. It was at this point i gave her the elbow.
Well, after poking the posh out of her tight ****
I was seeing a girl last year, her dad was multi millionaire, diddnt have to work if he chose not to but he did,so upper class?? but he was a prize ****. His daughter thought she was better than everyone else as she had more money. She used to joke, referring my home and surrounding area as being a council estate. Every house is 4 bed or more, houses valued from around £3 to £7 hundred K. Not lots in some peoples views but not poor. It was at this point i gave her the elbow.
Well, after poking the posh out of her tight ****
#55
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Cardiff. Wales
Posts: 11,758
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Parents were born into working class families but father worked his way up to be a director of a FTSE100 company. Myself Ive got bugger all qualifications but have worked hard all my life and now earn 3X + average wage and through investments I could retire now at 47 if I wanted to.
Even so I still think of myself as working class.
Chip
Even so I still think of myself as working class.
Chip
#56
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Not the Wild West
Posts: 1,567
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#57