550i or 535d?
#91
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
The only other down side of the Panamera is that it doesn't have that proper family car boot ie like a M5, E63, RS6 etc as far as I can tell.
#93
Scooby Senior
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Passing ...............
Posts: 13,320
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Deep, has the flywheel been checked on the M5 ? Is it a dual mass one ? Speaking to a friend earlier about it as he's had a couple of M5's & not had that problem with any of them but did say his E39 suffered from a vibration from the flywheel. Nightmare to diagnose, surely our local BMW tech "rookymatt" could advise ?
Last edited by sti-04!!; 23 November 2010 at 01:51 PM.
#94
Scooby Regular
Deep,
You've admitted that this is a stop gap car, so all the issues about feeling short changed in the 535d over the 550i are irrelevant. As a stop gap car it is by its very nature a compromise.
What you need to think about is what will you be happy with as a compromise until you buy the new M5.
In reality, for those three occasions a year when the 550 will be ultimately a little bit quicker than the 535d (or the guy in the other car), will you feel worse that you're in the "slower" car, or will you feel better due to the fact that the nominal extention to your ***** will probably have cost you £20k, when you factor in increase in purchase price, tax, fuel and depreciation.
For 99% of your motoring, the diesel will probably be quicker anyway.
Here's the crux of this. You've gone to great lengths to assert that this is not about dick swinging, and yet it appears that the main reason for anyone chosing a 550 over a 535d (in the uk at least) is simply to have the "ultimate" which is not always the best. If that isn't dick swinging then I'm not sure what is.
In that sense, you've answered your own question. Get the 535d in the knowledge that the upside 99% of the time far outways the 1% downside, in the knwoledge that you have the best diesel engine currently on sale today, in the knowledge that when you come to trade it in the main dealer will welcome you with a smile and a deal to be done on a new M5, and in the knowledge that you will have saved a fortune over the guy in the 550.
You've admitted that this is a stop gap car, so all the issues about feeling short changed in the 535d over the 550i are irrelevant. As a stop gap car it is by its very nature a compromise.
What you need to think about is what will you be happy with as a compromise until you buy the new M5.
In reality, for those three occasions a year when the 550 will be ultimately a little bit quicker than the 535d (or the guy in the other car), will you feel worse that you're in the "slower" car, or will you feel better due to the fact that the nominal extention to your ***** will probably have cost you £20k, when you factor in increase in purchase price, tax, fuel and depreciation.
For 99% of your motoring, the diesel will probably be quicker anyway.
Here's the crux of this. You've gone to great lengths to assert that this is not about dick swinging, and yet it appears that the main reason for anyone chosing a 550 over a 535d (in the uk at least) is simply to have the "ultimate" which is not always the best. If that isn't dick swinging then I'm not sure what is.
In that sense, you've answered your own question. Get the 535d in the knowledge that the upside 99% of the time far outways the 1% downside, in the knwoledge that you have the best diesel engine currently on sale today, in the knowledge that when you come to trade it in the main dealer will welcome you with a smile and a deal to be done on a new M5, and in the knowledge that you will have saved a fortune over the guy in the 550.
Last edited by Devildog; 23 November 2010 at 02:45 PM.
#96
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Deep, has the flywheel been checked on the M5 ? Is it a dual mass one ? Speaking to a friend earlier about it as he's had a couple of M5's & not had that problem with any of them but did say his E39 suffered from a vibration from the flywheel. Nightmare to diagnose, surely our local BMW tech "rookymatt" could advise ?
I am going to send Rookymatt a pm and see if he might meet up with me for 'drink' and have a look at the car.
#101
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
That's scary, you seem to know me too well
Your comments re 535d vs 550 are of course right. When I posed the question I thought I might keep the car for longer ie 2-3 years. I thought perhaps I had finally shaken my foolish addiction to certain kinds of cars and wasting money. I thought I was finally going to be grown up and sensible.
When I had a longer think about it I realised I was only fooling myself. When that M5 is unveiled in 2011 I'm going to want one, and I will justify the ridiculous cost and depreciation by saying 'life is short/you're a long time dead' type statements.
That's when the new purchase turned into a stop gap car. For that you are 100% correct, the 535d MS is the right choice compared to a 550i.
The best solution is though to try and hang onto the current M5. There is a little issue here as well though and I'd appreciate yours (and others opinions)
Lets say I keep the M5 for 12-18 months. The current px price is £18k, so in 18 months time it will be ? £12k?
Lets say it also costs me a few thousand to have it fixed, lets say £3k.
In those 18 months it will also need some new tyres, and minor service so say another £1000.
There are also the big fuel bills of the M5, in a year I can get through £3k of fuel at an average 13mpg (SUL). The 535d ms will give at least 20mpg of cheaper diesel so I will have spent an extra £1.5k on fuel.
So, to keep the M5 it will cost me
£6k +£3k+£1.5k+£1k = £11.5k
(I've not included insurance etc as that will be the same)
So if I bought the 535d MS would I lose much more than that over 18 months if I then sold as a private sale? In that 18 months the car will only have about 10k miles on it.
Would I not be able to sell an 18 month old fully specced low mileage 535d with a rrp of £55k (I'm paying £50k) for £35k? In which case I will have only spent £5k more than the M5 would have cost but will have had the pleasure of a brand new car. Also no chance of a major bill.
Thanks to all for taking the time to read.
Last edited by Dingdongler; 23 November 2010 at 05:38 PM.
#104
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
#105
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
#108
Scooby Senior
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Passing ...............
Posts: 13,320
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The M5 will be worth closer to 14k I reckon but the flip side is that dealers will be paying 33 to 36k for the 35d ms. All IMHO though. Your logic above is spot on.
I'd plump for the 35d, the M5 could develop another fault with even more repair costs. I can't fault BMW when it comes to vehicles 'within' there warranty period. Outwith this they scare the sh!te out of me.
I'd plump for the 35d, the M5 could develop another fault with even more repair costs. I can't fault BMW when it comes to vehicles 'within' there warranty period. Outwith this they scare the sh!te out of me.
#111
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 15,271
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My 530d has done over 90k miles.
Faults are wide and varied...
...errrr, there are no faults
New front discs twice, washer bottle motor went a couple of times. Rear wash wipe hinge corroded and was replaced. That's about it in 90k miles.
Faults are wide and varied...
...errrr, there are no faults
New front discs twice, washer bottle motor went a couple of times. Rear wash wipe hinge corroded and was replaced. That's about it in 90k miles.
#112
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 15,271
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Private warranty will need plenty of research to ensure you are covered. If my engine failed most of them would barely cover the diagnosis of failure (even if there was a rod out the block!!!)
#113
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Ok, sorry to drag this out, I can tell you guys are getting a bit bored by all of this, however the discussion has been very useful for me so thank you.
Now, any ideas what colour I should order?
Seriously though, what do you think? I usually go for black, but the only black available in this car is the carbon black which has a slight blue tinge to it. Alpine white I think only looks good for proper sports models (ie M3, future M5), dark blue is boring and metallic sophisto grey can look a bit nondescript in dull lighting. That only leaves titanium silver.
Titanium silver
http://f10.5post.com/forums/showthread.php?t=456034
Carbon black (pics don't show the blue tinge)
http://f10.5post.com/forums/showthread.php?t=451540
Carbon Black
Now, any ideas what colour I should order?
Seriously though, what do you think? I usually go for black, but the only black available in this car is the carbon black which has a slight blue tinge to it. Alpine white I think only looks good for proper sports models (ie M3, future M5), dark blue is boring and metallic sophisto grey can look a bit nondescript in dull lighting. That only leaves titanium silver.
Titanium silver
http://f10.5post.com/forums/showthread.php?t=456034
Carbon black (pics don't show the blue tinge)
http://f10.5post.com/forums/showthread.php?t=451540
Carbon Black
#114
Ours is carbon black.
Looks stunning when clean and it's sunny
http://i252.photobucket.com/albums/h...P3280032-1.jpg
(sorry about the shameless pic... and you can't really see the blue tinge, either )
Looks stunning when clean and it's sunny
http://i252.photobucket.com/albums/h...P3280032-1.jpg
(sorry about the shameless pic... and you can't really see the blue tinge, either )
Last edited by zip106; 23 November 2010 at 10:01 PM.
#115
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Thanks Zippy.
Final question guys.
The dealer offered to waive the 2.5% VAT rise if I take delivery of the car before March. I would probably get the car just before then ie end of Jan, middle of Feb. The saving equates to £1100. Is the saving worth having the 'older' plate?
Thanks
Final question guys.
The dealer offered to waive the 2.5% VAT rise if I take delivery of the car before March. I would probably get the car just before then ie end of Jan, middle of Feb. The saving equates to £1100. Is the saving worth having the 'older' plate?
Thanks
#116
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Jan 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 15,271
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Do people car about plates anymore?
BTW Titanium is one of the longest running production car colours and has been on BMWs list over 35 years. It is a mainstay colour and you will never have a problem shifting a Titanium car.
BTW Titanium is one of the longest running production car colours and has been on BMWs list over 35 years. It is a mainstay colour and you will never have a problem shifting a Titanium car.
#119