Deja Vu (Libya)
#61
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Home
Posts: 14,758
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The news on the side of the revolt does seem ever more pessimistic. What I'm wondering is how the UN etc are going to squirm out of this if Gaddafi does succeed in crushing the revolt. We're surely in a position now where we've pretty much totally alienated him, meaning that western countries may actually be forced to take action in the end... because what are relations going to be like if he brings things back to 'normal' in Libya under his rule?
#62
Scooby Regular
it is certainly "clear as mud" the whole region looks a mess tbh
in Iraq -- they have been protesting against the same governmental corruption, chronyism, and general malaise in any form of institutional democracy/fairness that the Egyptians, Libyians, and Tunisians have been protesting against.
Iraq security forces shot dead 12 protestors, one wonders what would happen if a popular revolt took hold there, who would we side with
in Iraq -- they have been protesting against the same governmental corruption, chronyism, and general malaise in any form of institutional democracy/fairness that the Egyptians, Libyians, and Tunisians have been protesting against.
Iraq security forces shot dead 12 protestors, one wonders what would happen if a popular revolt took hold there, who would we side with
Last edited by hodgy0_2; 08 March 2011 at 10:02 PM.
#63
Guest
Posts: n/a
The news on the side of the revolt does seem ever more pessimistic. What I'm wondering is how the UN etc are going to squirm out of this if Gaddafi does succeed in crushing the revolt. We're surely in a position now where we've pretty much totally alienated him, meaning that western countries may actually be forced to take action in the end... because what are relations going to be like if he brings things back to 'normal' in Libya under his rule?
Dave
#64
#65
Exactly what I was thinking. Old Mrs Clinton (she does look old now BTW ...) was on the TV earlier saying he should go. Haven't heard from Billy Liar recently, you know, Gaddafi's best mate .... Reckon our oil contracts (British Petroleum doncha know ...) might be "re-negotiated" if he does keep power.
Dave
Dave
Any kind of force from other countries should certainly be sanctioned by the UN based on the treatment of civilians during the battle.
If he does win I expect that all his oil will go in a different direction to where it did before.
Les
#67
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Home
Posts: 14,758
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
He does have a lot of military force on his side and I think he could win back control of the country, especially with the treatment of captured rebels.
Any kind of force from other countries should certainly be sanctioned by the UN based on the treatment of civilians during the battle.
If he does win I expect that all his oil will go in a different direction to where it did before.
Les
Any kind of force from other countries should certainly be sanctioned by the UN based on the treatment of civilians during the battle.
If he does win I expect that all his oil will go in a different direction to where it did before.
Les
#69
Scooby Regular
We're in a spot, aren't we? I wonder what the anti-West posters like f1_fan would like to see. Intervention or not. Let's ignore our interests, briefly, and ask whether we have a moral and humanitarian obligation to support the rebels if it is requested by the majority. Remember what happened to the Shia in Iraq after Gulf War 1?
#70
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: Weston Super Mare, Somerset.
Posts: 14,102
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Perhaps a no-fly zone is the thin end of the wedge? So we wipe out his aircraft so he just rolls out his tanks and blows the place to bits. So what does the West do then?
dl
dl
#71
Scooby Regular
I heard a military analyst say that an enforced no fly zone is just a euphemism for war anyway
#72
Scooby Regular
personaly i dont think the extra cost is a mjor issue.
Training is no substitue for combat, so will help keep our pilots in tip top form in case there ever needed.
Training is no substitue for combat, so will help keep our pilots in tip top form in case there ever needed.
#73
Hypothetical question, Les: If the rebels were being slaughtered and the UN were unable to provide a resolution for intervention (no-fly zone, for example) owing to a veto by one or more permanent members, should the UK and the US and France et. al. remain inactive? Imagine that the veto comes from the members alluded to in your final paragraph.
It is a moot point whether a no fly zone should be established over Libya if the aircraft are being used to kill Libyan people. I would hope that UNO would come out with a positive recommendation for such a situation.
A unilateral attack on Libya whch is not approved by the UN would be illegal as was the attack on Iraq and would probably lead to similar problems, both in the country concerned and worldwide.
What would you do under the present circumstances?
Les
#74
We can't do this; it will meaning bombing anti-aircraft assets and that invariably means pictures of Libyan kids killed by western bombs at some point.
We gotta let the Libyans work this out even if it means Libya sliding into being a failed state
We gotta let the Libyans work this out even if it means Libya sliding into being a failed state
#75
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (9)
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: .
Posts: 20,035
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The only way we, as in the West, should get involved militarily is with a firm UN resolution (something the Obama administration actually seem to understand unlike his predessor) and with the backing of the Arab states not to mention the Libyan people.
We also need to have a proper plan as to what happens next i.e. once Gadaffi has gone. Do we really need another Afghanistatn/Iraq?
I would also like to know how having been told we, as in the UK, have to cut back on military spending can afford to get involved?
We also need to have a proper plan as to what happens next i.e. once Gadaffi has gone. Do we really need another Afghanistatn/Iraq?
I would also like to know how having been told we, as in the UK, have to cut back on military spending can afford to get involved?
#76
Scooby Regular
Nothing wrong with policing the world IMO, as long as it's done by people who want to do so. Still, this isn't really practical enough to be relevant to the situation in Libya right now. But Libya is the tip of the iceberg when it comes to stuff like this.
#77
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Home
Posts: 14,758
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
We are signatories to UNO and therefore should abide by the decisions of that organisation, advisory or not.
It is a moot point whether a no fly zone should be established over Libya if the aircraft are being used to kill Libyan people. I would hope that UNO would come out with a positive recommendation for such a situation.
A unilateral attack on Libya whch is not approved by the UN would be illegal as was the attack on Iraq and would probably lead to similar problems, both in the country concerned and worldwide.
What would you do under the present circumstances?
Les
It is a moot point whether a no fly zone should be established over Libya if the aircraft are being used to kill Libyan people. I would hope that UNO would come out with a positive recommendation for such a situation.
A unilateral attack on Libya whch is not approved by the UN would be illegal as was the attack on Iraq and would probably lead to similar problems, both in the country concerned and worldwide.
What would you do under the present circumstances?
Les
#79
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Home
Posts: 14,758
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#82
I would go with the government's position - I get that we need a UN resolution (we were desperate to secure this prior to 2003) and I absolutely understand the desire for Arab backing (and think we'll get it). What troubles me is this: Gaddafi can't stay in power, but will fight to the death and it would seem that the rebels lack the capability to remove him. This appears to lead to one possible outcome: Military intervention. What I can't square is what we do should the Russians (and possibly China) use their veto to block a mandate. What then? Do we stand by and watch as he carries out bloody reprisals? Look on as other dictators around the globe learn that the way to address a popular uprising is to turn guns and bombs on the people?
Ghaddafi wont give up power until he is forced to and the likely massacres to come are a terrible thought. I sincerely hope that the UN find an effective way to stop the killing.
Les
#84
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: Weston Super Mare, Somerset.
Posts: 14,102
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I see the Arab League are now supporting a no-fly zone and asked the West to get on with it. But why pass the buck to the UN and the West, haven't they got any planes to get on with it themselves without passing the poisoned chalice to us?
I thought we had been flogging millions of quids worth of military kit to the Saudis over the years, isn't that how Mark Thatcher got rich?
Thoughts?
PS. Gadaffi must think Christmas has come early with the Japanese diverting media attention for a week or so.
dl
I thought we had been flogging millions of quids worth of military kit to the Saudis over the years, isn't that how Mark Thatcher got rich?
Thoughts?
PS. Gadaffi must think Christmas has come early with the Japanese diverting media attention for a week or so.
dl
#86
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: Weston Super Mare, Somerset.
Posts: 14,102
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yes, minor stuff at present. But if it got serious and they brought down the House of Saudi that would be an awful lot of s,hit hitting a very big fan.
The mother of all headaches for the West if that happened and don't even think about the effect on the oil price
dl
The mother of all headaches for the West if that happened and don't even think about the effect on the oil price
dl
#88
#89
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Home
Posts: 14,758
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts