Pittys sti

Hi. I've been told that i've probably fried a piston by my mechanic. I've been quoted £1500-2500 to repair. Does this sound about right or is there anyone in the south-west who can do it cheaper?

Also I've had a few offers for it as it is. What Do you think it's worth? y2k bugeye, 27k miles and very good condition in blue.

Any help would be really appreciated.

172sport

iTrader: (6)

Sounds about right for a fix, the problem you have is it will be worth nothing if you sell it as a non runner.

Pittys sti

I've had offers of nearly £5k and i'm quite tempted to save the hassle of repairs to be honest. I'm not 100% sure of the damage yet either.

Northern Nick

iTrader: (1)

You could get a new 2.5 sti short motor for £1500 and it shouldn't cost more than a £1000 to fit it.

172sport

iTrader: (6)

not cost effective IMHO, dont forget a ballpark £500 on mapping if going that route

Northern Nick

iTrader: (1)

Yes, but think of it as an upgrade, same again or a 2.5 rebuild for the price of remap. Thats how i would look at it.

Pittys sti

I would probably go for the upgrade if I could afford it. But my bank/wife say different.

ex-webby

Pittys STi,
I have a standard STi8 Spec C tall engine available (better heads and cams than the V7 I believe). Will take 400+.

26k miles, perfect running order.

£2250.00

Regards,
Shaun

Pittys sti

Thanks for the offer, but im potless at the moment. Probably going to have to sell it as it is and accept the loss.

markietay

How did you fry it ????

Pittys sti

Hi. I've just added another post explaining what happened. To be honest I'm not even sure if thats the problem. The mechanic who said it was piston failure also offered to buy it in the same breath.

dunx

iTrader: (3)

Only 'cos he'd do the work for free and sell for a profit, or keep for himself.

IMHO

DunxC

Pittys sti

That did cross my mind. I also wondered if perhaps he's saying it's re-build time because he knew i'd be left with no choice but to sell it then.

Mark A

iTrader: (1)

2nd opinion may be, could talk to API

Pittys sti

Who's API? Also is there any way of finding the most likely problem without stripping the engine?

ustolemyname??stevieturbo

iTrader: (1)

Any competent mechanic should be able to tell based on compression, and leakdown tests, as well as how the car runs at present

If they cant....well....that seems to be common, which is a pity.

A bore scope would allow them to see inside to inspect the piston crown for damage, although a lot of them might not have such a tool.

Pittys sti

How would you expect a car to run if it doe's have piston damage? I've been told it down on compression on piston 4. Thanks for the advice.

ustolemyname??stevieturbo

iTrader: (1)

It would run mostly on 3 cylinders obviously, depending on the damage. If there was enough damage, it would be pressurising the crankcase, and chucking oil out the breathers, and possibly exhaust too ( if it can make it past the cat ).
The plug from that hole, would also be oily, or have oily deposits.

It would be very easy for any decent mechanic to diagnose.

Pittys sti

I take it a little damage is not much better than alot of damage repair wise? Still an engine out job I'd guess.

Mark A

iTrader: (1)

API they advertise on Scoobynet

website here API Engines

Speak to David

GROWLER_GRRRR

pitty sent you pm re swap for car

jimser

iTrader: (1)

think you've been mis-informed mate

Mark A

iTrader: (1)

Engine out and swap short engine, plus various other NEW components, modine & oil pump.

Could look at short engine from the states with the current exchange rate try Home standard 2.5 US STi is $1700. Ron at RAW is very helpful