Poll: Are you religious
#1
Poll: Are you religious
PLEASE NOTE THIS IS NOT A POLE OF WHAT RELIGION (IF ANY) THAT YOU FOLLOW!!
Last edited by jjones; 20 December 2004 at 09:49 AM. Reason: CAN'T ADD THE POLL NOW! WHAT A CROCK
#5
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: cuddly wobbly jelly land
Posts: 447
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by ajm
He may still be editing the poll......
Pending a "proper" poll: No, I am not religious - I see it as weak mindedness.
Pending a "proper" poll: No, I am not religious - I see it as weak mindedness.
#7
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: cuddly wobbly jelly land
Posts: 447
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by ajm
So I see!
The benefit of doubt was thrown back in my face!
The benefit of doubt was thrown back in my face!
*scratches head*
Trending Topics
#8
Originally Posted by ajm
He may still be editing the poll......
Pending a "proper" poll: No, I am not religious - I see it as weak mindedness.
Pending a "proper" poll: No, I am not religious - I see it as weak mindedness.
a common view....but history/current affairs show us many strong minded religous people.
if people arent thats fine but to to say "no...because its crap/for the weak/cause of probs" etc is like that person crediting faith with more than they suggest its worth by their apparent need to CLEARLY distance it from the "right" way.
#10
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: The biosphere
Posts: 7,824
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Tiggs
a common view....but history/current affairs show us many strong minded religous people.
I make the distinction between strong wills and strong minds because strong will drives us to physical extremes, whereas a strong mind is required to venture outside of the protective shell of a religion to make desicions for ourselves and to accept that we are responsible and ultimately answerable for ourselves and our actions, not some omnipotent being. A strong mind is required to conduct oneself in a becoming fashion without the threat of eternal damnation or the dangled carrot of heaven to constrain our behaviour.
There are pleanty of weak minded non-religious people as well by the way!
#11
Scooby Regular
I do believe in a higher being, I also think it is supremely arrogant to believe that we are the superior race.
But I also believe that organised religion is the oldest, and still the best method for deeply corrupt & morally bankrupt people to gain control over huge masses of people. Witness the religious & political leaders of India & Pakistan whipping up trouble in the previously peaceful Kashmir region, or Greece & Turkey, and their continual sabre rattling over Cyprus. Or look at the way religious fundamentalists managed to hijack an election to ensure the return of the most unpopular president the US has ever had
But I also believe that organised religion is the oldest, and still the best method for deeply corrupt & morally bankrupt people to gain control over huge masses of people. Witness the religious & political leaders of India & Pakistan whipping up trouble in the previously peaceful Kashmir region, or Greece & Turkey, and their continual sabre rattling over Cyprus. Or look at the way religious fundamentalists managed to hijack an election to ensure the return of the most unpopular president the US has ever had
#12
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: The land of Daisies and Bubbles!
Posts: 5,560
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think religious beliefs are deeply personal and not to be judged by others. I've got a scientific background - but for the life of me can't explain how we got here and what makes us 'alive'.
I'm not a fan of organised religion - too often people are busy being religious and simply not christian enough. They'll bash you over the head with the bits of the bible they like and ignore the bits that make things uncomfortable for them ("Judge not lest ye be judged" seems to go right over many of their heads!)
This life isn't easy for any of us - and whatever helps you get through it in one piece is your own personal choice.
Religious beliefs should never be forced on others - and I find it hard to accept that there is only 'one way' - after all if there is a God that is clever enough to create a whole planet of different people - surely you'd allow for them to all make their own way too you? (Rather like going from London to Manchester - same destination, but lots of different routes)
I'm not usually this philosphical until I've had a few!
I'm not a fan of organised religion - too often people are busy being religious and simply not christian enough. They'll bash you over the head with the bits of the bible they like and ignore the bits that make things uncomfortable for them ("Judge not lest ye be judged" seems to go right over many of their heads!)
This life isn't easy for any of us - and whatever helps you get through it in one piece is your own personal choice.
Religious beliefs should never be forced on others - and I find it hard to accept that there is only 'one way' - after all if there is a God that is clever enough to create a whole planet of different people - surely you'd allow for them to all make their own way too you? (Rather like going from London to Manchester - same destination, but lots of different routes)
I'm not usually this philosphical until I've had a few!
#13
I have always found that those who follow religious teachings are very strong minded. They have to be to keep to that kind of self discipline.
I was brought up with a scientific background as well and cannot see why that should affect one's religious or not beliefs in all honesty. One does not gainsay the other in any way in fact.
Les
I was brought up with a scientific background as well and cannot see why that should affect one's religious or not beliefs in all honesty. One does not gainsay the other in any way in fact.
Les
#14
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: South Bucks
Posts: 811
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I find organised religion to be a cancer of the human spirit. It is one of the main obstacles to any hope we have of developing as a race/species. I dont think we can ever expect to reach our full potential until we throw off our superstitious shackles.
Religion feeds on the insecurity, doubt and existential fear that most of us experience at one time or another. I have no problem with the central tenets of religion but i don't need a supernatural overlord to tell me how to live my life and treat other people. It is humanist common sense.
Religion feeds on the insecurity, doubt and existential fear that most of us experience at one time or another. I have no problem with the central tenets of religion but i don't need a supernatural overlord to tell me how to live my life and treat other people. It is humanist common sense.
#15
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: The biosphere
Posts: 7,824
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Leslie
I have always found that those who follow religious teachings are very strong minded. They have to be to keep to that kind of self discipline.
It takes a strong will to make oneself adhere to such a lifestyle regardless of doubt, but it takes a strong mind to question the rationality of what they are doing.
If you were to take all the "good" bits out of a religion, i.e. all the bits about selfless living, respecting others you will find that they can all be achieved without having to perform rituals or even the essential religious ingredient, an unshaking belief in the existence of a god.
People who can live a virtuous life without the promise of a place in heaven, or the threat of a place in hell are the truly strong minded.
I don't consider myself amongst them by the way, as my life is far from virtuous!
#16
I am atheist, but have a strong respect for religion and those that follow it.
I think religion was essential for civilised society - most of our laws are derived from the 10 Commandments. As soon as mankind became intelligent enough to ask "where did we come from?", religion sprouted up as an answer to an unanswerable question. It has been a much needed crutch for peoples all around the world for millennia.
However important it was in the formation of civilised societies though, it has also had its disadvantages - corrupt religious leaders and many (if not all) wars over the centuries for example.
For the record, I had a religion neutral upbringing. Interestly, I am atheist, yet my sister is very religious.
I think religion was essential for civilised society - most of our laws are derived from the 10 Commandments. As soon as mankind became intelligent enough to ask "where did we come from?", religion sprouted up as an answer to an unanswerable question. It has been a much needed crutch for peoples all around the world for millennia.
However important it was in the formation of civilised societies though, it has also had its disadvantages - corrupt religious leaders and many (if not all) wars over the centuries for example.
For the record, I had a religion neutral upbringing. Interestly, I am atheist, yet my sister is very religious.
#18
Not at all. Closest I come to religious is shouting "CHRIST THAT F**KING HURT" if I hit my thumb with a hammer. I also DO have a problem with those that are overtly religious to the point of using it as an excuse for what many would deem unethical behaviour (I'm talking about the ethics of humanity not religion). I also hate the way religious issues and racism are so often confused, the two are not inextricably linked. The most annoying thing however is that, as a Muslim, Abu Hansa can stand on his soapbox, in what is traditionally a Christian country, and denounce Christianity to the point of calling all Christians in general evil infidels, yet if a Christian were to do the same about Muslims in general they'd soon see the wrong side of a cell door.
It's wrong and it's inconsistent. As a religion Christians are so afraid of upsetting anyone that they'll allow the majority to be walked over by the minority.
Personally I have no prejudices whatsoever. I think they're all tossers.
It's wrong and it's inconsistent. As a religion Christians are so afraid of upsetting anyone that they'll allow the majority to be walked over by the minority.
Personally I have no prejudices whatsoever. I think they're all tossers.
#20
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Between the Fens and the Wolds.
Posts: 3,027
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm Pagan. I believe in the seasons, the Earth, water, air etc. I have no problem with what or who others believe in but I do despise those who try to thrust their beliefs upon others. Or those who insist that what /who they believe in is/are better than anything else.
Having said all that, I truely believe that we are placed here on this earth to live out our lives as best we can without harm nor hindrance to others. I work my belief on the basis of an all surrounding being and do not pretend to ask any favours, because we get ourselves into our own messes and have to learn how to get out of them . Belief to me is a comfort. Nothing more. Nothing magic, nothing supernatural. Just there.
Having said all that, I truely believe that we are placed here on this earth to live out our lives as best we can without harm nor hindrance to others. I work my belief on the basis of an all surrounding being and do not pretend to ask any favours, because we get ourselves into our own messes and have to learn how to get out of them . Belief to me is a comfort. Nothing more. Nothing magic, nothing supernatural. Just there.
#21
Originally Posted by Jap2Scrap
The most annoying thing however is that, as a Muslim, Abu Hansa can stand on his soapbox, in what is traditionally a Christian country, and denounce Christianity to the point of calling all Christians in general evil infidels,
Originally Posted by Jap2Scrap
yet if a Christian were to do the same about Muslims in general they'd soon see the wrong side of a cell door.
He can have his views, but if he preaches hatred and provokes, then he has to be shut.
#22
ajm,
I agree with your point about some religious teaching instilling a fear of what might happen to those who behave badly with respect to the doctrines of that religion. I think that is usually a personal trait of the particular teacher involved as much as anything. I dont subscribe to that sort of thing.
As people gain experience of life however, and gain self confidence, they tend to take a more overall view of life and temper their beliefs with their own common sense. I remember during my 6th form education attending Apologetics classes where all religions including paganism, atheism, agnosticism, and satanism were thoroughly discussed and investigated with no bias being shown in any one direction. We were absolutely free and expected to give our own honest views without prejudice. We were also free to follow our own beliefs. I think that is how it should be.
As you say, religions generally have good bits and they do encourage people to live good lives with diue regard to the welfare of others. I think that if people are not shown some form of guidance when they are young in how to lead their lives in a responsible manner, then the most likely course they will follow is a bad one. We see that everywhere now and I think a lot of that is because of the extremely secular society that we live in today. No one is perfect and we all do regrettable things in our lives. Its all a matter of degree of course. Those who have had no education in how to live in a peaceful and fair society are the ones who will be most likely to commit the really shameful acts.
Religious teachings did a lot to reduce that possibilty.
Jap to Scrap,
It really is most unfair and particularly ill mannered if you don't mind me saying so, to call religious followers a bunch of tossers, if that is how I read your post.
Incidentally Abu Hamza is entitled to denounce Christianity if he wishes, its when he encourages his young followers to commit murderous terrorist acts that he is promoting sedition and that is quite rightly not allowed.
Les
I agree with your point about some religious teaching instilling a fear of what might happen to those who behave badly with respect to the doctrines of that religion. I think that is usually a personal trait of the particular teacher involved as much as anything. I dont subscribe to that sort of thing.
As people gain experience of life however, and gain self confidence, they tend to take a more overall view of life and temper their beliefs with their own common sense. I remember during my 6th form education attending Apologetics classes where all religions including paganism, atheism, agnosticism, and satanism were thoroughly discussed and investigated with no bias being shown in any one direction. We were absolutely free and expected to give our own honest views without prejudice. We were also free to follow our own beliefs. I think that is how it should be.
As you say, religions generally have good bits and they do encourage people to live good lives with diue regard to the welfare of others. I think that if people are not shown some form of guidance when they are young in how to lead their lives in a responsible manner, then the most likely course they will follow is a bad one. We see that everywhere now and I think a lot of that is because of the extremely secular society that we live in today. No one is perfect and we all do regrettable things in our lives. Its all a matter of degree of course. Those who have had no education in how to live in a peaceful and fair society are the ones who will be most likely to commit the really shameful acts.
Religious teachings did a lot to reduce that possibilty.
Jap to Scrap,
It really is most unfair and particularly ill mannered if you don't mind me saying so, to call religious followers a bunch of tossers, if that is how I read your post.
Incidentally Abu Hamza is entitled to denounce Christianity if he wishes, its when he encourages his young followers to commit murderous terrorist acts that he is promoting sedition and that is quite rightly not allowed.
Les
Last edited by Leslie; 22 December 2004 at 01:23 PM.
#23
"Jap to Scrap,
It really is most unfair and particularly ill mannered if you don't mind me saying so, to call religious followers a bunch of tossers, if that is how I read your post.
Incidentally Abu Hamza is entitled to denounce Christianity if he wishes, its when he encourages his young followers to commit murderous terrorist acts that he is promoting sedition and that is quite rightly not allowed.
Les"
It really is most unfair and particularly ill mannered if you don't mind me saying so, to call religious followers a bunch of tossers, if that is how I read your post.
Incidentally Abu Hamza is entitled to denounce Christianity if he wishes, its when he encourages his young followers to commit murderous terrorist acts that he is promoting sedition and that is quite rightly not allowed.
Les"
I also think you contradict yourself there Les because if Abu Hamza has the right to denounce Christianity then surely I have the right to denounce any or all religions and if my way of denouncing them is to call them tossers then it's not unfair in the slightest.
#24
Jap2Scrap,
You are of course as entitled to denounce religious beliefs if that is what you believe. I did not say that you are not.
The impression I got from your post was that you regard all Christians as "tossers" and that is why I said it was ill mannered and unfair to be insulted like that for one's honest beliefs. It does nothing to strengthen the argument either. Not all Christians are prepared to allow themselves to be "walked over" either.
I would go along with the idea that someone who is not prepared to accept that everyone is entitled to his own personal beliefs and not just to those of the bigoted person himself is wrong to take such an attitude.
Les
You are of course as entitled to denounce religious beliefs if that is what you believe. I did not say that you are not.
The impression I got from your post was that you regard all Christians as "tossers" and that is why I said it was ill mannered and unfair to be insulted like that for one's honest beliefs. It does nothing to strengthen the argument either. Not all Christians are prepared to allow themselves to be "walked over" either.
I would go along with the idea that someone who is not prepared to accept that everyone is entitled to his own personal beliefs and not just to those of the bigoted person himself is wrong to take such an attitude.
Les
Last edited by Leslie; 28 December 2004 at 04:03 PM.
#25
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: Mansfield Area
Posts: 1,126
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have my religion and believe what I have been bought up to believe, I do not impose my self on anyone else. So I do not expect to have other religions imposed on me. And regarding Abu Hamza there is no wonder people are accused as being racist having to listen to his vile preaching. Best thing for him and his followers is a holiday back to Afghanistan. I also believe this is why Britain has never been attacked, reason we are to tolerant with these people. We let them operate from this country
#26
BANNED
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: LIVERPOOL THE CENTRE OF EXCELLENCE
Posts: 8,511
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I believe in no religion...
And have been to a church less than 10 times in my life.
But.
A funny thing happened last year on Christmas Eve.
I got ****faced, as usual, but stopped off at a church for midnight mass, dont ask...
I havent the faintest idea why.
Anyway, I was drinking white spirits and I shouldnt, it makes me cry, and try to find the meaning of life, you know how it is.......
So Im sat there bladdered, asking these questions in my head.
Then the next day thought nothing of it, my mates on the other hand thought it was most amusing.
10 months later my son was born, mad as ****. Not planned, not even talked about.
I remember most of the questions, and they revolved around, "What am I here for, there must be more to life that getting bladdered and having a fight at the taxi rank."
Anyway, I go quite often now..
Edited to say.
I did post at the time of the incident, but cant find the post.
And have been to a church less than 10 times in my life.
But.
A funny thing happened last year on Christmas Eve.
I got ****faced, as usual, but stopped off at a church for midnight mass, dont ask...
I havent the faintest idea why.
Anyway, I was drinking white spirits and I shouldnt, it makes me cry, and try to find the meaning of life, you know how it is.......
So Im sat there bladdered, asking these questions in my head.
Then the next day thought nothing of it, my mates on the other hand thought it was most amusing.
10 months later my son was born, mad as ****. Not planned, not even talked about.
I remember most of the questions, and they revolved around, "What am I here for, there must be more to life that getting bladdered and having a fight at the taxi rank."
Anyway, I go quite often now..
Edited to say.
I did post at the time of the incident, but cant find the post.
Last edited by yoza; 28 December 2004 at 11:14 PM.
#27
Cooking on Calor
iTrader: (23)
imho it was a story that was told to kids, that got out of proportion, I think its all just that a story, dont believe in it never have never will.
if there was a god, would YOUR god have done what he did to all those 59k and counting people?
I do however believe in aliens, because if we can exist here, then id say there must be other living organisms out there, be it algy form, or being form, (not little green men) as thats doubtfull, but if we can exist, then surely in the same/similar conditions elsewhere other "organisms" could live/exist.
just my 20 and a half pence
jamo
if there was a god, would YOUR god have done what he did to all those 59k and counting people?
I do however believe in aliens, because if we can exist here, then id say there must be other living organisms out there, be it algy form, or being form, (not little green men) as thats doubtfull, but if we can exist, then surely in the same/similar conditions elsewhere other "organisms" could live/exist.
just my 20 and a half pence
jamo
#28
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: The Muddy Wasteland that is the Thames Estuary
Posts: 318
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by jjones
PLEASE NOTE THIS IS NOT A POLE OF WHAT RELIGION (IF ANY) THAT YOU FOLLOW!!
Internet Professional JJones