IPOD or Sony Walkman?
#1
IPOD or Sony Walkman?
Looking for some advice please. I'm looking to purchase either one of the new Ipods, Nano or Video, or a decent MP3 player, maybe the new Sony Walkman.
I've no idea how the Ipod system works though, can I load my own music or am I limited to downloads from Itunes. I know the Ipod has some odd copyright protection and I believe you can't load MP3 files.
Any advice welcome.
I've no idea how the Ipod system works though, can I load my own music or am I limited to downloads from Itunes. I know the Ipod has some odd copyright protection and I believe you can't load MP3 files.
Any advice welcome.
#2
I'm not expert but I believe you can download MP3 to the iPod with no problems.
Knowing Sony you are much more likely to have copyright / download issues with the walkman - you certainly do with the minidisc system .
Knowing Sony you are much more likely to have copyright / download issues with the walkman - you certainly do with the minidisc system .
#4
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (2)
Can't comment on the problems, or otherwise, with downloads.
I DO know, however, that the iPods have reliability problems. My youngest is on his third "Nano", his mate is on his second early model, two others have still to take theirs back............
Meanwhile, my Sony 20GB MP3 unit just soldiers on
Alcazar
I DO know, however, that the iPods have reliability problems. My youngest is on his third "Nano", his mate is on his second early model, two others have still to take theirs back............
Meanwhile, my Sony 20GB MP3 unit just soldiers on
Alcazar
#5
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Swilling coffee at my lab bench
Posts: 9,096
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why restrict your choice to Apple or Sony? There are plenty of other perfectly good players out there that don't include any spurious 'protection' nor lock you into the whole iKnowbest routine.
Take a look at www.mp3players.co.uk or www.advancedmp3players.co.uk and you'll see, there's loads of choice. You'll struggle to find any unit that won't play MP3, most will do WMA, and some will play OGG too. Typically you just plug the device into a USB port, it appears as a hard drive, and you just drag & drop files onto it using Windows, Mac OS or Linux.
Take a look at www.mp3players.co.uk or www.advancedmp3players.co.uk and you'll see, there's loads of choice. You'll struggle to find any unit that won't play MP3, most will do WMA, and some will play OGG too. Typically you just plug the device into a USB port, it appears as a hard drive, and you just drag & drop files onto it using Windows, Mac OS or Linux.
#6
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (2)
Originally Posted by AndyC_772
Why restrict your choice to Apple or Sony? There are plenty of other perfectly good players out there that don't include any spurious 'protection' nor lock you into the whole iKnowbest routine.
Take a look at www.mp3players.co.uk or www.advancedmp3players.co.uk and you'll see, there's loads of choice. You'll struggle to find any unit that won't play MP3, most will do WMA, and some will play OGG too. Typically you just plug the device into a USB port, it appears as a hard drive, and you just drag & drop files onto it using Windows, Mac OS or Linux.
Take a look at www.mp3players.co.uk or www.advancedmp3players.co.uk and you'll see, there's loads of choice. You'll struggle to find any unit that won't play MP3, most will do WMA, and some will play OGG too. Typically you just plug the device into a USB port, it appears as a hard drive, and you just drag & drop files onto it using Windows, Mac OS or Linux.
What he said
Alcazar
#7
Had a Sony NW-HD1 for nearly a year now. No problems whatsoever.
20GB hard drive with 30 hours playback on a full charge. Sits in a charge cradle that connects up to a USB port. My version is the old-old one which only supports ATRAC but Sony's software encodes from MP3/CDA to ATRAC on the fly. The newer models - HD3, HD5 and the latest all support native MP3 with no conversion.
As Andy and Alcazar say - don't limit your choice, there are loads of models out there. The first decision you need to make is do you want solid state memory or a hard drive? Consider looking at iRiver and Creative products
20GB hard drive with 30 hours playback on a full charge. Sits in a charge cradle that connects up to a USB port. My version is the old-old one which only supports ATRAC but Sony's software encodes from MP3/CDA to ATRAC on the fly. The newer models - HD3, HD5 and the latest all support native MP3 with no conversion.
As Andy and Alcazar say - don't limit your choice, there are loads of models out there. The first decision you need to make is do you want solid state memory or a hard drive? Consider looking at iRiver and Creative products
Trending Topics
#8
Originally Posted by AndyC_772
Why restrict your choice to Apple or Sony? There are plenty of other perfectly good players out there that don't include any spurious 'protection' nor lock you into the whole iKnowbest routine.
Take a look at www.mp3players.co.uk or www.advancedmp3players.co.uk and you'll see, there's loads of choice. You'll struggle to find any unit that won't play MP3, most will do WMA, and some will play OGG too. Typically you just plug the device into a USB port, it appears as a hard drive, and you just drag & drop files onto it using Windows, Mac OS or Linux.
Take a look at www.mp3players.co.uk or www.advancedmp3players.co.uk and you'll see, there's loads of choice. You'll struggle to find any unit that won't play MP3, most will do WMA, and some will play OGG too. Typically you just plug the device into a USB port, it appears as a hard drive, and you just drag & drop files onto it using Windows, Mac OS or Linux.
#11
Scooby Regular
Ipod
Pros: looks fantastic, user interface is great, no restrictions on MP3, does the job
Cons: slightly overpriced, reliability is a little suspect, tied into iTunes too much, doesn't support WMA (whether you want that is another matter), battery life isn't great
Sony
Haven't really used the Sony (just played with one in the shops), but personally the colours are horrible and the design isn't as nice as the iPod. Should have a colour screen IMHO.
Pros: looks fantastic, user interface is great, no restrictions on MP3, does the job
Cons: slightly overpriced, reliability is a little suspect, tied into iTunes too much, doesn't support WMA (whether you want that is another matter), battery life isn't great
Sony
Haven't really used the Sony (just played with one in the shops), but personally the colours are horrible and the design isn't as nice as the iPod. Should have a colour screen IMHO.
#12
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Derbyshire
Posts: 12,304
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think this was covered a little while back. You can load MP3 by hand in to an iPOD but it requires some jiggery pokery. You can also use iTunes, which some people seem to like. While you shouldn't be using copy protected stuf any way, I don't think you will have any problems with iTunes (Yet). Personally I'd go for some generic HD MP3 player that can be accessed the same as USB external Hard Drive as a fall back.
#13
Scooby Regular
There is no problems using non-copyrighted MP3's with iTunes. I've never used *and don't want to use) copyright music formats. I just rip my CD's and stick them straight into my iTunes library and upload them to my iPod.
#14
I would go for an Ipod..30 million people cant be wrong..I must admit I was against buying an Ipod at first and did not want to pay £50 more just so I could have an ipod.I opted for a creative player and what a load of crap that was.I took it back after a month and got an Ipod.
Every song I had already on my pc was automatically converted and copied into Itunes so it does play all formats after it converts them..
Another reason for the Ipod is there are so many accessories for it..
Every song I had already on my pc was automatically converted and copied into Itunes so it does play all formats after it converts them..
Another reason for the Ipod is there are so many accessories for it..
#15
have used Itunes on the pc for ages- got Mrs a 30gb ipod for birthday at the weekend and its superb, just plug and play.
also got the Bose docking speakers for the kitchen so she can listen to it while cooking! Great sound from a little unit.
T
also got the Bose docking speakers for the kitchen so she can listen to it while cooking! Great sound from a little unit.
T
#16
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Mar 1999
Location: The Great White North
Posts: 25,080
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Have a look at all MP3 players in your price range, see which one fits your needs.
Personally I would go for an iPod, but I'm an Apple Geek, so that's part of the reason.
As for getting music onto it, you will need to use iTunes, which is the simple method, or third party software if you don't want to use iTunes for some odd reason. It will accept MP3 files, if it did not then I'd be screwed as the majority of my music is in MP3 format. You are not limited to downloading tracks from the iTunes Music store either. For example, you could use allofmp3.com and download tracks from there and they will work perfectly on the iPod.
You can also rip CD's into iTunes to get your existing music collection onto it. I think the default these days for iTunes is to encode into AAC rather than MP3, but the iPod will play that anyway, or you could change the format it rips CD's as to MP3.
Personally I would go for an iPod, but I'm an Apple Geek, so that's part of the reason.
As for getting music onto it, you will need to use iTunes, which is the simple method, or third party software if you don't want to use iTunes for some odd reason. It will accept MP3 files, if it did not then I'd be screwed as the majority of my music is in MP3 format. You are not limited to downloading tracks from the iTunes Music store either. For example, you could use allofmp3.com and download tracks from there and they will work perfectly on the iPod.
You can also rip CD's into iTunes to get your existing music collection onto it. I think the default these days for iTunes is to encode into AAC rather than MP3, but the iPod will play that anyway, or you could change the format it rips CD's as to MP3.
#27
Hello
I don't know why no-one can produce something that matches the Ipod. I'm just as bad as everyone else. I went to look at the Nano as a present for my wife and it is just amazing. It is probably $100 (I'm in America today) more than something that is better from a functional and memory perspective but it just doesn't look or feel as good.
If I was Creative or Sony I would just go to my designers : "Look, like that .. only cooler, don't worry about the other stuff". Like Sony did with the PSP actually.
Steve
I don't know why no-one can produce something that matches the Ipod. I'm just as bad as everyone else. I went to look at the Nano as a present for my wife and it is just amazing. It is probably $100 (I'm in America today) more than something that is better from a functional and memory perspective but it just doesn't look or feel as good.
If I was Creative or Sony I would just go to my designers : "Look, like that .. only cooler, don't worry about the other stuff". Like Sony did with the PSP actually.
Steve
#28
Scooby Senior
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: West Yorks.
Posts: 4,130
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think the iPod also has a big advantage in that it can play Apple Lossless music files which, although bigger in size sound a load better (when you ditch the OE headphones and buy some decent ones)
#29
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Brighton no more
Posts: 2,170
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Also, due to the much larger customer base, there are loads more things you can buy to go with your iPod; this was the reason I got one (i.e. Alpine interface to my HU).
http://bbs.scoobynet.co.uk/showthrea...27#post4676827
http://bbs.scoobynet.co.uk/showthrea...27#post4676827