+Doc+

Not another one of those threads....
Getting itchy car feet again and cant decide what to go for next.
Escort Cossie or a P1 / Sti V ltd 555

Trying to weigh up the pros and cons of both got this far...

Escos Pros:
Rare
Highly Tuneable
Look Fantastic
Lots of nice examples about
Cons:
Expensive to buy
Old
Thieves/Jelous Tw@ts favourite target

P1 Pros:
Rare ( in a specials sense)
Fast from standard
Better prices than Escos
Newer
Cons:
Expensive to run
As above

The misses likes the Escos more I like the P1 more :|
Anyone had both? Lucky b`stards

scoobynutta555

Had a P1 for 4 years never had a escosth although i always wanted one when i was younger. If youre after the P1 you can pick up full history standard with subaru warranty still. The cosworths will be around 10 years old plus by now and wont have a manufacture warranty. Standard the P1 would win hands down IMHO

p1prodrive

iTrader: (3)

another vote here for the p1 i have had it a year and never regret it at all!

plus and extra 60bhp or there abouts more than the ecos and still allot newer.

ecos is still a very nice car mind

Patt@firstime

Ive had a P1 but would have an esc cos just for the looks

Andy M3

I would prefer the Escort Cosworth - the standard Cosworth looks a peach i think. The P1 has not done it for me like the 22B did - which would be my choice out of the 2. Or a STI 5 Type R i would have over a P1 ????

Personal preferance though - all great cars in there own right, but in 10-15 years time, picture the scene in the Pub chatting away talking about legendary cars - i think the Escort ownership would be a more memorable claim than the P1 ???

prodriva

Or, to really tip the scales, how about a SKYLINE GTR??? If your looking at mint condition escos and P1's your budget must be £15k-20k. That should get you a tidy GTR with stupid performance and equally as rare as the escos

rizla06

I would have thought an Escort Cossie would hold it's price far better, from what I've seen they all seem to be increasing in prices.

dave cos4x4

Are you going to use it as an everyday car.

if so, i would go for the P1.



Dave.

Johnny50

Agree with Dave.
Everyday car..P1.
Almost every day car, i`d be struggling to choose between Sti and Esc Cos.

+Doc+

Thanks for the replies.
Skyline would be a push to fit in my garage
It wont be used everyday as I get a lift to work.
Budget 12k ish
Im swaying towards the P1 or similar the more I think about it.

rizla06

That would count out an Escort cossie then, my mate searched a long time for one and ended up paying a lot more for a decent one. The ones round the 12k mark he looked at were all high mileage and well used.

stu_5

For 12k your better off going for a type-r looking at current p1 prices.

That money will either get you a very tatty p1 or an immaculate type-r.

Know which I'd rather have.

Gav

Another vote for a V5 type r. Just better than a P1 IMHO and a cossie.

Gav..