Are short journeys harmful?
#1
Thread Starter
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Nov 2012
Posts: 422
Likes: 0
From: Coedpoeth, North Wales
Are short journeys harmful?
I'm starting work in Chester tomorrow (Live in Wrexham) and the commute is a nightmare apparently so I'm going to get the train, at least initially.
I can park at a friends house near the station which will work out at just under 4 miles each way.
I've heard people say short journeys in performance cars isn't a good thing, is this true? I change the oil every 3-4k and take it out on 60mile+ trips a couple of times a month
I can park at a friends house near the station which will work out at just under 4 miles each way.
I've heard people say short journeys in performance cars isn't a good thing, is this true? I change the oil every 3-4k and take it out on 60mile+ trips a couple of times a month
#4
It's not a round trip of 8 miles either. It's a single trip of less than 4 miles twice a day.
But you believe what you believe I suppose.
Trending Topics
#10
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 15,029
Likes: 0
From: Somewhere in Kent, sniffing some V-Power
Can you imagine the stick that Subaru would get if they said that you couldn't drive the car on short journeys? The motoring press would have a field day.
Just drive it sensibly and change the oil every 6 months.
You will be fine.
Just drive it sensibly and change the oil every 6 months.
You will be fine.
#11
Have you seen Subaru UK warranty, Id be surprised if that wasn't on there to get out of paying these claims on the 2.5 engines!!
#13
#16
I thought when the water temp was up to it's normal peak the oil was also at its peak
#18
OMG!!!
Or 90 degrees?
You know what my guess mark is not working on my keyboard and I keep asking questions.
the / button works though but when I press shift+/ it doesn't do anything, so annoying.
Or 90 degrees?
You know what my guess mark is not working on my keyboard and I keep asking questions.
the / button works though but when I press shift+/ it doesn't do anything, so annoying.
#19
in essence your water temperature will get there MUCH quicker then your oil temperature, dont use your water temp as a guide, get a set of gauges or seriously consider taking a lot longer and getting more temp into the oil before stretching the cars legs.
#20
#21
I sincerely didn't realise oil would still need extra time to get to optimum temps.
I'm using the Thomas stuff too! 10/50
#22
I'm starting work in Chester tomorrow (Live in Wrexham) and the commute is a nightmare apparently so I'm going to get the train, at least initially.
I can park at a friends house near the station which will work out at just under 4 miles each way.
I've heard people say short journeys in performance cars isn't a good thing, is this true? I change the oil every 3-4k and take it out on 60mile+ trips a couple of times a month
I can park at a friends house near the station which will work out at just under 4 miles each way.
I've heard people say short journeys in performance cars isn't a good thing, is this true? I change the oil every 3-4k and take it out on 60mile+ trips a couple of times a month
Something running say 10w60 with an oil cooler can take 20+ minutes to get up to temperature.
I've recently fitted a set of Genomes to my S202 and it takes ages for the oil to heat up.
IIRC the OP will be running a forged 2.5 and running quite a thick oil so would be best to drive off boost for at least 15 minutes after starting the car.
#23
You may throw your insults, chav boy, but I wasn't actually taking the p1ss out of you (on this occasion). I was merely pointing out that I'd expect 95% or more of people just get in their cars and drive without a clue or care what the oil temp is, because it's not shown
Also ... who in their right mind is going to drive it 5 or 6 miles before planting it? Ain't nobody got time for that!
Also ... who in their right mind is going to drive it 5 or 6 miles before planting it? Ain't nobody got time for that!
#24
It does depend on spec but a regular UK car running the recommended 5w30 oil will heat up very quickly.
Something running say 10w60 with an oil cooler can take 20+ minutes to get up to temperature.
I've recently fitted a set of Genomes to my S202 and it takes ages for the oil to heat up.
IIRC the OP will be running a forged 2.5 and running quite a thick oil so would be best to drive off boost for at least 15 minutes after starting the car.
Something running say 10w60 with an oil cooler can take 20+ minutes to get up to temperature.
I've recently fitted a set of Genomes to my S202 and it takes ages for the oil to heat up.
IIRC the OP will be running a forged 2.5 and running quite a thick oil so would be best to drive off boost for at least 15 minutes after starting the car.
Doesn't an oil cooler bother with a thermostat/
#25
Moderator
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 38,052
Likes: 301
From: The hell where youth and laughter go
Short journeys in ANY car is bad for them.
The oil dilutes with fuel and water from combustion gets into the oil causing it to degrade, become corrosive and allow condensation to build and create nice creamy gunk. Making idiot/internet mechanics think your head gasket has gone. This is obviously worse in the winter due to the colder temps. Its degraded and contaminated oil that kills engines, not how cold it is.
The answer? Simples. Take it for a "proper" drive once a week where the engine has a good hour to run. Doesn't have to be hard driving, just be driven long enough to boil off the nasty stuff out through the breather system.
Alternatively change the oil more often. Or better - do both.
PS...I never bother warming up/cooling down. Just get in an drive. I have to hoof it out onto the busy dual-carriage way at the end of my road on a daily basis; Its not something I like doing, but to totter out on that road would be suicide. Done that in every car I've owned, none had any engine issues.
The oil dilutes with fuel and water from combustion gets into the oil causing it to degrade, become corrosive and allow condensation to build and create nice creamy gunk. Making idiot/internet mechanics think your head gasket has gone. This is obviously worse in the winter due to the colder temps. Its degraded and contaminated oil that kills engines, not how cold it is.
The answer? Simples. Take it for a "proper" drive once a week where the engine has a good hour to run. Doesn't have to be hard driving, just be driven long enough to boil off the nasty stuff out through the breather system.
Alternatively change the oil more often. Or better - do both.
PS...I never bother warming up/cooling down. Just get in an drive. I have to hoof it out onto the busy dual-carriage way at the end of my road on a daily basis; Its not something I like doing, but to totter out on that road would be suicide. Done that in every car I've owned, none had any engine issues.
Last edited by ALi-B; 08 October 2014 at 01:22 AM.
#27
On the contrary. Short journeys don't warm the engine up sufficiently to evaporate any condensation that might accumulate in the crankcase. The oil won't get up to proper operating temperature in 4 miles and so cannot work to it's best advantage at a time when the engine is in need of good protection from wear and tear.
It's not a round trip of 8 miles either. It's a single trip of less than 4 miles twice a day.
But you believe what you believe I suppose.
It's not a round trip of 8 miles either. It's a single trip of less than 4 miles twice a day.
But you believe what you believe I suppose.
My oil's up to temp (Defi tells me so) in less than a MILE some days.
Depends on the traffic, and if it's commuter type then 5 mins and you're warm enough.
Cold/Winter days and if you use the demister before you set off, probably up to temp in a few hundred yards.
#28
That's assuming that both dash and Defi guages are in sync.
#29
#30
Agree - gauges help. I live 15 minutes from work. A mix of 60 A roads and 70 dual. Never take it above 3K until the oil is approaching 90. It gets to 90 at the end of the journey in this cold weather - I travel at around 6.30 am, with an ambient temp of around 4-8 at the moment. Water is up to temp after about 3-5 mins of driving. My knock sensor (via the Toucan multi-gauge) tends to get excited if you load it up when it's cold - leason learned a few years back, never done it since.